Shippo vs Pirate Ship: which does AI recommend?

Since May 29 · · ChatGPT and Google AI Mode

Based on 151 AI responses that name bothReviewed by

How we measure

When AI names both, it lists first slightly more often. It recommends and warns against both about as often.

Head to head

Listed first when AI names both

ShippoShippo: 54% (Shippo leads)Pirate ShipPirate Ship: 46%

Recommended when named

ShippoShippo: 100%
Pirate ShipPirate Ship: 97%

Warned against · lower is better

ShippoShippo: 0%
Pirate ShipPirate Ship: 2%

Pick Shippo for

  • Comparing rates and bulk labels Usually
  • Importing orders and bulk labels Almost always

Pick Pirate Ship for

  • Online stores Usually
  • Retail shops Almost always

Who AI mentions first

Shippo listed firstPirate Ship listed first

has been listed first more often since September; before then, was listed first more often. October is 's strongest month yet.

  1. JunShippo listed first: 54%Pirate Ship listed first: 46%
  2. JulShippo listed first: 71%Pirate Ship listed first: 29%
  3. AugShippo listed first: 75%Pirate Ship listed first: 25%
  4. SepShippo listed first: 35%Pirate Ship listed first: 65%
  5. Oct, so farShippo listed first: 23%Pirate Ship listed first: 77%

ChatGPT Search usually lists first, and Google AI Mode lists first more often than not. Claude usually lists first, so the engines lean to different brands.

  • ChatGPTShippo listed first: 76%Pirate Ship listed first: 24%
  • Google AI ModeShippo listed first: 61%Pirate Ship listed first: 39%

Other brands AI mentions

and appear in most of these answers, with appearing in about half.

Shippo vs Pirate Ship: common questions

Is Shippo better than Pirate Ship?
Shippo is ahead for comparing carrier rates and printing labels in bulk, and for importing orders from an e-commerce platform and printing labels in bulk. Pirate Ship is ahead for online stores and retail shops; answers are level on comparing rates and printing labels from multiple carriers.
Do ChatGPT and Google AI Mode recommend Shippo or Pirate Ship?
ChatGPT Search usually lists Shippo first, and Google AI Mode lists Shippo first more often than not. Claude usually lists Pirate Ship first, so the engines lean to different brands.
What are the alternatives to Shippo and Pirate Ship?
ShipStation and Easyship appear in most of these answers, with Veeqo appearing in about half.
When is Shippo the better pick?
AI usually lists Shippo first for: Comparing rates and bulk labels; Importing orders and bulk labels.
When is Pirate Ship the better pick?
AI usually lists Pirate Ship first for: Online stores; Retail shops.

How would your brand compare?

See how your brand compares in AI answers.