Nationwide vs Progressive: which does AI recommend?

Since May 31 · · ChatGPT and Google AI Mode

Based on 305 AI responses that name bothReviewed by

How we measure

AI summary

The claims point to for dwelling coverage rates and to for a no-exam term quote, while the answers split overall. When both brands are named, is listed first more often.

Head to head

Listed first when AI names both

NationwideNationwide: 34%ProgressiveProgressive: 66% (Progressive leads)

Recommended when named

NationwideNationwide: 62%
ProgressiveProgressive: 72% (Progressive leads)

Warned against · lower is better

NationwideNationwide: 1%
ProgressiveProgressive: 1%

Pick Progressive for

  • Insurance company options Usually
  • Car insurance Usually

Topic by topic

Nationwide named more7About even2Progressive named more16

Nationwide named more

Progressive named more

About even2

Only Nationwide is ranked in12

Only Progressive is ranked in12

What people ask AI about Nationwide and Progressive

Nationwide listed firstProgressive listed first
  1. which insurance companies are there for me?Progressive usually first
  2. What is the best car insurance?Progressive usually first
  3. which car insurance brand is best for me?Nationwide often first
  4. Where can I get affordable student car insurance?Leans Progressive
  5. Where can I find cheapest full-coverage car insurance?Progressive often first
  6. I have two cars and a house. What is the best website for finding the biggest discount on a home and auto insurance bundle?Progressive usually first
  7. I want to switch my car insurance to a usage-based provider.Leans Progressive
  8. where can I get tenant insurance quotes?Progressive almost always first

Who AI mentions first

Nationwide listed firstProgressive listed first

is listed first every month.

  1. JunNationwide listed first: 42%Progressive listed first: 58%
  2. JulNationwide listed first: 35%Progressive listed first: 65%
  3. AugNationwide listed first: 17%Progressive listed first: 83%

Every engine leans to when both brands are named. Google AI Mode leans more, while ChatGPT Search lists first slightly more often.

  • Google AI ModeNationwide listed first: 28%Progressive listed first: 72%
  • ChatGPTNationwide listed first: 42%Progressive listed first: 58%

Also named alongside Nationwide and Progressive

and appear in most of these answers, and appears in many.

  1. State Farm77%
  2. GEICO71%
  3. USAA60%
  4. Travelers54%
  5. Allstate48%
  6. Erie Insurance29%
  7. Amica28%
  8. Liberty Mutual27%
  9. The Zebra24%
  10. Insurify15%
  11. Auto-Owners Insurance15%
  12. Compare13%

Nationwide vs Progressive: common questions

Is Nationwide better than Progressive?
The claims point to Progressive for dwelling coverage rates and to Nationwide for a no-exam term quote, while the answers split overall. When both brands are named, Progressive is listed first more often.
Do ChatGPT and Google AI Mode recommend Nationwide or Progressive?
Every engine leans to Progressive when both brands are named. Google AI Mode leans more, while ChatGPT Search lists Progressive first slightly more often.
What are the alternatives to Nationwide and Progressive?
State Farm and GEICO appear in most of these answers, and Erie Insurance appears in many.
When is Progressive the better pick?
AI usually lists Progressive first for: Insurance company options; Car insurance.

Related comparisons

How would your brand compare?

See how your brand compares in AI answers.