Minted vs Shutterfly: which does AI recommend?

· ChatGPT and Google AI Mode

Based on every AI answer that names bothReviewed by

How we measure

AI summary

The answers treat and as equal picks overall; when an answer names both, it usually lists first.

Listed first when AI names both

MintedMinted: 80% (Minted leads)ShutterflyShutterfly: 20%

Recommended when named

MintedMinted: 93%
ShutterflyShutterfly: 93%

Pick Minted for

  • Save-the-date cards Usually
  • Wedding thank-you cards Usually
  • Custom birthday cards Usually

Topic by topic

Mentioned in, as a share of each topic’s answers

Minted named more6About even1Shutterfly named more9

Minted named more

Shutterfly named more

About even1

Only Minted is ranked in10

Only Shutterfly is ranked in9

What people ask AI about Minted and Shutterfly

is listed first usually for save-the-date cards and wedding thank-you cards.

Minted listed firstShutterfly listed first
  1. where can i get save-the-date cards online?Minted usually first
  2. Where can I print wedding thank you cards?Minted usually first
  3. Where's the best place to order custom birthday cards online?Minted usually first
  4. I'm looking for a unique housewarming gift for friends who just bought a home. What is the best site for personalized items like a custom doormat or address stamp?Level

Who AI mentions first

Minted listed firstShutterfly listed first

is listed first every month.

  1. JunMinted listed first: 65%Shutterfly listed first: 35%
  2. JulMinted listed first: 84%Shutterfly listed first: 16%
  3. AugMinted listed first: 88%Shutterfly listed first: 12%
  4. SepMinted listed first: 81%Shutterfly listed first: 19%

Google AI Mode and ChatGPT Search list first; Google AI Mode leans more.

  • Google AI ModeMinted listed first: 85%Shutterfly listed first: 15%
  • ChatGPTMinted listed first: 73%Shutterfly listed first: 27%

Also named alongside Minted and Shutterfly

appears in most of these answers; and appear in about half.

  1. Vistaprint61%
  2. Canva49%
  3. Zazzle43%
  4. Etsy42%
  5. Zola35%
  6. Paperless Post26%
  7. The Knot19%
  8. Walgreens Photo19%
  9. Papier16%
  10. Hallmark15%
  11. Basic Invite14%
  12. FedEx Office13%

Minted vs Shutterfly: common questions

Is Minted better than Shutterfly?
The answers treat Minted and Shutterfly as equal picks overall; when an answer names both, it usually lists Minted first.
Do ChatGPT and Google AI Mode recommend Minted or Shutterfly?
Google AI Mode and ChatGPT Search list Minted first; Google AI Mode leans more.
What are the alternatives to Minted and Shutterfly?
Vistaprint appears in most of these answers; Canva and Zazzle appear in about half.
When is Minted the better pick?
AI usually lists Minted first for: Save-the-date cards; Wedding thank-you cards; Custom birthday cards.

Related comparisons

How would your brand compare?

Find out where you stand in AI answers—and who you’re up against.