Madgicx vs Smartly: which does AI recommend?

· ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode

Based on every AI answer that names bothReviewed by

How we measure

When AI names both, it lists first more often than not. It recommends and warns against both about as often.

Listed first when AI names both

MadgicxMadgicx: 64% (Madgicx leads)SmartlySmartly: 36%

Recommended when named

MadgicxMadgicx: 73%
SmartlySmartly: 65%

Warned against · lower is better

MadgicxMadgicx: 0%
SmartlySmartly: 5%

Topic by topic

Mentioned in, as a share of each topic’s answers

Madgicx named more1Smartly named more1

Madgicx named more

Smartly named more

Only Madgicx is ranked in2

Only Smartly is ranked in5

What people ask AI about Madgicx and Smartly

Madgicx listed firstSmartly listed first
  1. I'm spending too much on social media ads. What's the best tool for a paid social specialist to optimize ad campaigns?Madgicx often first
  2. What is the best ad management platform?Leans Smartly

Who AI mentions first

Madgicx listed firstSmartly listed first
  • ChatGPT SearchMadgicx listed first: 63%Smartly listed first: 38%

Sources cited in the comparisons

Madgicx favouredNeither favouredSmartly favoured

Also named alongside Madgicx and Smartly

  1. Birch71%
  2. Optmyzr31%
  3. Meta Ads29%
  4. Triple Whale24%
  5. AdRoll14%
  6. Cometly14%
  7. Skai14%
  8. Google Ad Manager12%
  9. Google Ads12%
  10. Meta12%
  11. Ryze AI12%
  12. Hootsuite10%

Related comparisons

How would your brand compare?

Find out where you stand in AI answers—and who you’re up against.