Allstate vs Nationwide: which does AI recommend?

Since May 29 · · ChatGPT and Google AI Mode

Based on 234 AI responses that name bothReviewed by

How we measure

When AI names both, it lists first more often than not. It recommends both about as often.

Head to head

Listed first when AI names both

AllstateAllstate: 65% (Allstate leads)NationwideNationwide: 35%

Recommended when named

AllstateAllstate: 73%
NationwideNationwide: 79%

Pick Allstate for

  • Insurance companies available Usually
  • Tenant insurance quotes Almost always
  • Online home insurance quotes Usually

Pick Nationwide for

  • Home, auto, business liability bundle Almost always

Topic by topic

Allstate named more11Nationwide named more7

Allstate named more

Nationwide named more

Only Allstate is ranked in9

Only Nationwide is ranked in12

What people ask AI about Allstate and Nationwide

Allstate listed firstNationwide listed first
  1. which insurance companies are there for me?Allstate usually first
  2. For a condo owner, which insurer offers the best specialized condo coverage that coordinates well with the HOA master policy?Nationwide often first
  3. I have two cars and a house. What is the best website for finding the biggest discount on a home and auto insurance bundle?Leans Allstate
  4. I want to switch my car insurance to a usage-based provider.Allstate often first
  5. where can I get tenant insurance quotes?Allstate almost always first
  6. As a small business owner with a home office, which insurer offers the best bundled package for home, auto, and small business liability?Nationwide almost always first
  7. where can i get home insurance quotes online?Allstate usually first
  8. Where can I get car insurance quotes?Allstate usually first

Who AI mentions first

Allstate listed firstNationwide listed first

is listed first every month, with August its strongest month yet.

  1. JunAllstate listed first: 63%Nationwide listed first: 37%
  2. JulAllstate listed first: 64%Nationwide listed first: 36%
  3. AugAllstate listed first: 65%Nationwide listed first: 35%
  • Google AI ModeAllstate listed first: 66%Nationwide listed first: 34%
  • ChatGPTAllstate listed first: 62%Nationwide listed first: 38%

Sources AI cites

Allstate favouredNeither favouredNationwide favoured

Other brands AI mentions

BrandMentioned in
  1. State Farm84%
  2. Progressive63%
  3. GEICO52%
  4. USAA50%
  5. Travelers44%
  6. Liberty Mutual33%
  7. Amica22%
  8. The Zebra21%
  9. Lemonade20%
  10. Erie Insurance20%
  11. Farmers Insurance18%
  12. American Family Insurance13%

Allstate vs Nationwide: common questions

What are the alternatives to Allstate and Nationwide?
AI most often names State Farm, Progressive, GEICO and USAA in the same answers.
When is Allstate the better pick?
AI usually lists Allstate first for: Insurance companies available; Tenant insurance quotes; Online home insurance quotes.
When is Nationwide the better pick?
AI usually lists Nationwide first for: Home, auto, business liability bundle.

Related comparisons

How would your brand compare?

See how your brand compares in AI answers.