Custom birthday cakes
Since Oct 13Updated Nov 3, 2026Based on 30 AI responses
Reviewed by Dimitry Apollonsky
Brands AI mentions
Also mentioned rarely: Abby's Cakes & Moore, Alani Bakery, Andy Cakes NYC, Annie's Baking Creations, Art2Eat Cakes, Bake Me A Wish! Personalized Photo Cake, Baker's Man, Cakey’s Cakes Cookies and Creations, Chocoholic Desserts, Baskin-Robbins, Blackbird Bakery, Bread Plus Bakery, Button Rock Bakery, Cake Crazy Bakery, Dreamtreats, Cakes by Steph LLC, Caroline's Cakes, CEG Bakery, Classic Bakery, CMNY Cakes, Costco, Creme De La Creme Cake Company, Cup and Cake Bakery, Custom Cakes by Liud, Dave's Cakes, de Lumière Pastry, Edibles Incredible, Elevation Cakes & Sweets, Fairy Cakes Bakeshop, Fig Tree Patisserie, Fleen’s Dessert Studio, Freedom Bakery, Frost Artisan Bakery, Giant Eagle, Golden Crumb Bakery, Sugar & Storm, Hive Bakery, Jessa's Bakehouse, Loft22 Cakes, Love at First Bite, Google Maps, Mia's Brooklyn, Pastry and More, Pâte à Cake, Publix, Rosewater Bakery, Sam's Club, Sam's Club Personalized Cakes, Shamane's Bakery, Specialty Cakes by Amanda, Sugar Bakery, Sugar Coma Treats, Sweet Sisters Bake Shop, Sweet Beginnings Bakery, Sweets By Selina, The Conche, The Bäkehaus, The Cake Shop, The Petite Cakery, Velvet Cake LLC, Torrance Bakery, Unforgettable Sweetz, The Velvet Buttercream, Wegmans, Whole Foods Market, With Love, Em Custom Cakes
| Mentioned in | ChatGPTChatGPT | Google AI ModeGoogle AI Mode |
|---|---|---|
| Icing On The Cake | 0% | 20% |
| Kroger | 0% | 20% |
| Bake Me A Wish | 0% | 13% |
| Love and Cake | 0% | 13% |
| The Cake Girl | 0% | 13% |
Questions and answers
ChatGPTNov 3, 2026
If you're looking around Burlington, Wisconsin and the surrounding Lake Geneva area, there are several excellent options for custom birthday cakes. I found a few local bakeries that stand out for artistic designs, personalized themes, and made-from-scratch cakes.
Best local bakeries for custom birthday cakes
1. Blackbird Bakery
(Best overall pick)
256 E Chestnut St, Burlington · 262-661-4029
- Custom party cakes and desserts.
- Creative, artistic designs.
- Made-from-scratch baking.
- Gluten-free options.
Website:
Especially good for a show-stopping birthday cake.
2. Annie's Baking Creations
34025 Bassett Rd, Burlington · 262-237-4771
- Custom birthday cakes and cupcakes.
- Homemade, small-batch baking.
- Custom orders for special occasions.
- Pickup in the Burlington area.
Website:
Great option for supporting a small local baker.
3. Pastries by Chad
29 N Wisconsin St, Elkhorn · 262-379-1187
- Custom celebration cakes.
- French-inspired pastry expertise.
- Personalized flavors and fillings.
- Strong customer feedback.
Worth considering for an elegant, detailed cake.
4. Genoa City Cake Co.
N1300 Clover Rd, Genoa City
- Custom birthday and celebration cakes.
- Personalized cake designs.
- Custom cookies also available.
- Small custom-order bakery.
A good choice for a personalized cake from a smaller bakery.
5. Julie Michelle Cakes
117 Kenosha St, Walworth
- Boutique custom cake studio.
- Beautiful buttercream detailing.
- Vintage-inspired piping and elegant designs.
- Appointment-based ordering.
My pick for sophisticated or vintage-style birthday cakes.
6. Sally's Sweet Shoppe
Genesee Depot · 262-968-1803
- Scratch-made celebration cakes.
- Rosette and tiered cakes.
- Custom cupcakes and decorated cookies.
- At least four business days' notice for cakes.
A nice option for classic, beautifully decorated cakes.
My top recommendations
What you're looking for My pick Elaborate custom designs Blackbird Bakery Kids' themed birthday cakes Blackbird Bakery Elegant, sophisticated designs Julie Michelle Cakes Small local baker Annie's Baking Creations Classic decorated cakes Sally's Sweet Shoppe Let's narrow down the perfect cake
I can help find bakeries that specialize in the exact style you're imagining.
What kind of birthday cake design are you looking for?
Themed / character cakes
Vintage / Lambeth cakes
Elegant / luxury cakes
Photo / personalized cakes
3D / sculpted cakes
Modern minimalist cakes
I can narrow this down to the best 3 cake artists within about 30 miles of Burlington, based on your preferred design and budget.
Sources cited in this answer2
Google AI ModeNov 3, 2026
- 1Icing On The Cake
- 2The Petite Cakery
- 3The Cake Girl
- 4With Love, Em Custom Cakes
To find the absolute best local bakery for your custom birthday cake, options can vary greatly depending on your specific area. However, several highly rated independent and specialty custom cake options across different regions include:
Better Butter Bakery 5.0 (90)
$100+Cake shop
Closed
Order CallDirections Website Better Butter Bakery : Mobile cake shop known for handcrafted, custom-designed milestone and themed birthday cakes with convenient delivery options.
With Love, Em - Custom Cakes 5.0 (25)
Bakery
Lehi, UT
OrderDirections Website With Love, Em - Custom Cakes : Highly-rated custom cake studio (Lehi, UT area) celebrated for incredible flavor balance, moist textures, and custom themed designs (including dietary-friendly options).
Icing on the Cake 4.6 (393)
$1–60 Bakery
Closed Colorado Springs, CO
Order CallDirections Website Icing on the Cake : A long-standing favorite in Colorado Springs, CO, specializing in turning detailed design visions and reference photos into reality.
The Petite Cakery 5.0 (19)
$10–20 Bakery
Lakewood, CO
CallDirections Website The Petite Cakery : Lakewood, CO-based boutique custom baker (advanced order only) praised for artistic designs and extensive allergy-friendly/gluten-free choices.
The Cake Girl 5.0 (41)
Cake shop
Closed
CallDirections Website The Cake Girl : Leander, TX-based custom specialist recognized for meticulous attention to thematic detail and rich flavor profiles.If you share your city, zip code, or neighborhood , I can pull up the highest-rated local custom cake bakeries right near you!
Google AI ModeNov 1, 2026
Most local and regional bakeries, as well as major supermarket bakeries, can create a custom cake featuring your photo—either by printing an edible image directly onto the cake surface or by hand-sculpting/decorating a 3D design to match the reference picture.
Types of Photo Cakes Available
- Edible Image / Photo Print Cakes:
- How it works: You upload or bring in your photo, and the bakery prints it using food-grade ink onto an edible frosting sheet (such as rice paper or sugar sheet) that sits flat on top of the cake.
- Where to get it: Major grocery chains and local bakeries (e.g., Kroger Custom Cakes or local spot options like Torrance Bakery for photo round cakes starting around $58.55 for an 8-inch size).
- Notice time: Usually requires 24 to 72 hours in advance.
- Hand-Sculpted or Custom-Designed 3D/Themed Cakes:
- How it works: You show the bakery a photo of a specific cake design, character, or object, and a cake artist recreates the structure, piped details, or fondant work by hand.
- Where to get it: Local independent boutique or specialty custom bakeries.
- Notice time: Typically requires 1 to 2 weeks in advance (longer for complex tiered or sculptural cakes).
Tips for Ordering a Photo Cake
- Clarify the Photo Type: Decide whether you want a flat edible photo print placed on the cake or a hand-crafted replica inspired by the photo.
- Check Image Resolution: If you are opting for an edible print, make sure the photo is high-resolution (clear, bright, and not overly compressed) so it prints sharply.
- Inquire About Lead Times: Standard photo-sheet cakes can often be ordered a few days ahead, whereas custom sculptural work needs much earlier booking.
- Confirm Flavors and Allergies: Ask what cake bases (e.g., yellow, chocolate, marble, red velvet), fillings, and icings (buttercream, whipped topping, cream cheese) are available.
To help me point you in the exact right direction, could you share:
- Your city or zip code (so I can find local bakeries near you)
- Whether you want an edible flat photo print or a 3D cake sculpted to match a picture?
ChatGPTNov 1, 2026
Absolutely! I found several bakeries in and around Waterford, Connecticut that may be able to turn your photo into a custom-designed cake.
The important distinction is whether you want the photo printed onto an edible image or want the bakery to recreate the actual cake design in your picture. I've included options for both.
My top bakery recommendations
1. Twisted Sugar Cake Design
(Worth contacting first)
Ledyard, CT · (860) 381-5834
Specializes in custom cake design. Customer feedback highlights their ability to take someone's vision and bring it to life.
Great for a detailed cake recreated from an inspiration photo.
2. Nessa's D'lights
Waterford, CT · (203) 202-5207
Local custom cake and dessert maker. Offers made-from-scratch celebration cakes and specialty desserts.
A convenient option right in Waterford.
3. Caked
Old Lyme, CT · (203) 984-4137
Custom cake studio specializing in bespoke celebration cakes.
Particularly promising for personalized designs and cakes requiring attention to detail.
4. Simply Sweet by Elana
Old Lyme, CT · Custom-order bakery
Specializes in made-to-order cakes and works closely with customers to create personalized designs.
5. BJ's Bakery
125 Cross Road, Waterford · (860) 437-3100
Offers celebration cakes, including photo-style cakes.
Best if you want your actual photograph printed on an edible image rather than a fully recreated cake.
A question that will help me narrow this down
Would you be willing to upload the photo of the cake you want made?
I can look at the design and help identify which bakery is most likely to recreate it.
For example:
- A cake recreated to look almost exactly like your picture.
- A character, sculpted, or 3D cake.
- A beautiful decorated birthday cake with specific colors and details.
- A regular cake with your actual photograph printed on top.
I can also help you find a bakery that will work from your exact reference photo rather than just offering a standard photo cake.
Upload your picture, and we'll find the right baker for it!
- Edible Image / Photo Print Cakes:
Also asked as
- I need a custom birthday cake designed; which local bakeries are the best for this?
