Best alternatives to Square for brick-and-mortar subscription management?

If you mean recurring memberships/subscriptions sold and redeemed in a physical store—not just recurring invoices—there are better Square alternatives depending on your business type.

My shortlist

1. vagaro.com — best overall for memberships

This would be my first choice if your subscription is really a membership.

Vagaro lets you create recurring memberships with different billing frequencies, discounts, service/product benefits, visit limits, auto-renewal, introductory pricing, and balance carry-forward. Customers can buy memberships directly at checkout, online, or through the business's booking site.

It also connects memberships to POS, scheduling, customer profiles, rewards, marketing, and reporting.

Best fit: salons, barbers, spas, fitness studios, wellness businesses, recurring service businesses.

Why I'd pick it over Square: Square's subscriptions are fundamentally recurring billing; Vagaro treats the membership itself as a business object that can control what the customer gets when they walk into your location.

---

2. mindbodyonline.com — best for fitness/wellness

If you're running a gym, yoga studio, Pilates studio, martial arts school, spa, or similar operation, Mindbody is a much more sophisticated membership platform.

It supports autopay memberships, stored cards, recurring payments, membership/class-pack sales, front-desk POS, scheduling and client management.

The tradeoff is cost and complexity: U.S. pricing currently starts at $79/month per location, before considering payment-related costs and optional add-ons.

Best fit: businesses where membership management is central to the business rather than an occasional recurring charge.

---

3. helcim.com — best if payment economics are the priority

Helcim is interesting if you want something closer to Square's simplicity but with better payment economics and more capable recurring billing.

Its recurring billing supports subscriptions, stored payment methods, ACH/EFT, automatic retries, and a customer portal. Helcim uses interchange-plus pricing rather than Square's flat-rate model.

Best fit: retail/service businesses where you don't need elaborate class scheduling or membership-access rules.

The big caveat: it's more of a payments/POS + recurring billing solution than a full-fledged membership-management platform like Vagaro or Mindbody.

---

4. clover.com — good general-purpose POS alternative

Clover is worth considering if your priority is replacing Square's physical POS infrastructure while retaining the ability to add subscription/membership functionality through its ecosystem.

It's particularly attractive if you want more hardware and payment-processing flexibility than Square, although the exact economics depend heavily on the Clover reseller/processor you use.

---

5. lightspeedhq.com — best for subscription + serious retail

I'd look at Lightspeed when the subscription is only one part of a larger retail operation.

For example:

Physical store → sophisticated inventory → purchasing → employees → multiple locations → recurring membership Lightspeed's strength is the retail infrastructure rather than membership management itself. Current U.S. comparisons put its retail plans substantially above basic Square pricing, but with considerably deeper inventory capabilities.

---

The important distinction

I'd choose differently depending on what you mean by "subscription."

If customers pay $30/month and receive something every month:

→ Vagaro / Mindbody

If customers pay $30/month simply for recurring access to a service:

→ Vagaro / Mindbody

If you're selling physical products plus a recurring subscription:

→ Lightspeed or Shopify POS + a subscription system

If you mainly want recurring payments and don't need elaborate membership rules:

→ Helcim

If you need extremely custom subscription logic:

→ Stripe + your POS

My ranking for a typical brick-and-mortar membership business

1. Vagaro — best balance of POS + memberships + recurring billing
2. Mindbody — best for sophisticated fitness/wellness memberships
3. Helcim — best if payment cost and simple recurring billing matter most
4. Clover — good general Square replacement
5. Lightspeed — best when inventory/retail complexity dominates

One particularly interesting option is not replacing Square at all: third-party membership layers can sit on top of Square. For example, MemberZone specifically positions itself as a recurring-membership/subscription layer that can continue using Square POS.

If you tell me what kind of brick-and-mortar business you have, number of locations, approximate monthly subscription volume, and whether subscribers get products/services/discounts/access, I can narrow this to the 3 best options and compare actual monthly + processing costs.

Vagaro lets you create recurring memberships with different billing frequencies, discounts, service/product benefits, visit limits, auto-renewal, introductory pricing, and balance carry-forward. Customers can buy memberships directly at checkout, online, or through the business's booking site.

It also connects memberships to POS, scheduling, customer profiles, rewards, marketing, and reporting.

Best fit: salons, barbers, spas, fitness studios, wellness businesses, recurring service businesses.

Why I'd pick it over Square: Square's subscriptions are fundamentally recurring billing; Vagaro treats the membership itself as a business object that can control what the customer gets when they walk into your location.

---

2. mindbodyonline.com — best for fitness/wellness

If you're running a gym, yoga studio, Pilates studio, martial arts school, spa, or similar operation, Mindbody is a much more sophisticated membership platform.

It supports autopay memberships, stored cards, recurring payments, membership/class-pack sales, front-desk POS, scheduling and client management.

The tradeoff is cost and complexity: U.S. pricing currently starts at $79/month per location, before considering payment-related costs and optional add-ons.

Best fit: businesses where membership management is central to the business rather than an occasional recurring charge.

---

3. helcim.com — best if payment economics are the priority

Helcim is interesting if you want something closer to Square's simplicity but with better payment economics and more capable recurring billing.

Its recurring billing supports subscriptions, stored payment methods, ACH/EFT, automatic retries, and a customer portal. Helcim uses interchange-plus pricing rather than Square's flat-rate model.

Best fit: retail/service businesses where you don't need elaborate class scheduling or membership-access rules.

The big caveat: it's more of a payments/POS + recurring billing solution than a full-fledged membership-management platform like Vagaro or Mindbody.

---

4. clover.com — good general-purpose POS alternative

Clover is worth considering if your priority is replacing Square's physical POS infrastructure while retaining the ability to add subscription/membership functionality through its ecosystem.

It's particularly attractive if you want more hardware and payment-processing flexibility than Square, although the exact economics depend heavily on the Clover reseller/processor you use.

---

5. lightspeedhq.com — best for subscription + serious retail

I'd look at Lightspeed when the subscription is only one part of a larger retail operation.

For example:

Physical store → sophisticated inventory → purchasing → employees → multiple locations → recurring membership Lightspeed's strength is the retail infrastructure rather than membership management itself. Current U.S. comparisons put its retail plans substantially above basic Square pricing, but with considerably deeper inventory capabilities.

---

The important distinction

I'd choose differently depending on what you mean by "subscription."

If customers pay $30/month and receive something every month:

→ Vagaro / Mindbody

If customers pay $30/month simply for recurring access to a service:

→ Vagaro / Mindbody

If you're selling physical products plus a recurring subscription:

→ Lightspeed or Shopify POS + a subscription system

If you mainly want recurring payments and don't need elaborate membership rules:

→ Helcim

If you need extremely custom subscription logic:

→ Stripe + your POS

If you have outgrown Square’s basic recurring billing or find its ecosystem too restrictive for a physical brick-and-mortar storefront that relies heavily on memberships, box subscriptions, or recurring service fees, several alternatives handle in-person subscription management much better.

The best choices depend on whether you are completely omnichannel or purely local:

• Shopify POS — Best for Omnichannel Retail & Subscriptions
  • How it works: Highly praised for bridging the gap between physical retail and online operations. Using the Shopify POS app alongside specialized subscription apps from their ecosystem (like Recharge or Appstle), your counter staff can sign in-store customers up for recurring local or shipped subscriptions right at the register.
  • Why it beats Square: Superior, unified inventory management across multiple physical and digital channels with far more robust third-party subscription app integrations.
• Lightspeed Retail — Best for Complex Inventory & Multi-Location Growth
  • How it works: A true retail-operations-first platform. Lightspeed handles heavy-duty inventory matrixes, advanced reporting, and customer profiles, and it supports recurring billing/account-on-file workflows essential for specialty brick-and-mortar shops (like wine clubs or hobby stores).
  • Why it beats Square: Square’s reporting and inventory controls can feel lightweight once you scale. Lightspeed gives you deep, actionable weekly analytics and enterprise-grade vendor and stock management.
• Helcim — Best for Lower Processing Fees on High Volume
  • How it works: Unlike Square's flat-rate pricing, Helcim uses an interchange-plus pricing model which automatically passes wholesale credit card processing savings down to you. It includes built-in virtual terminal, invoicing, and recurring/subscription tools with no monthly software fees.
  • Why it beats Square: If your in-person subscription volume is scaling past $25,000 to $50,000+ a month, Square’s flat rate becomes expensive, whereas Helcim’s interchange-plus rates and volume discounts offer substantial savings.
• Clover — Best for Dedicated Hardware & Processor Freedom
  • How it works: Backed by Fiserv, Clover provides robust all-in-one hardware terminals (from mobile Go devices to full Station registers) and an app market where you can plug in specialized recurring billing and customer management apps. Unlike Square, you aren't forced to use one specific payment processor.
  • Why it beats Square: Better hardware-software customization, stronger employee permission controls, and the flexibility to shop around for competitive merchant account processing rates.

To help narrow down the ideal fit, tell me:

• What kind of brick-and-mortar business do you run (e.g., gym, boutique, wine club, cafe)?
• Roughly what is your monthly processing volume?
• Do you also sell online , or is it 100% in-store?

When running a brick-and-mortar storefront that handles recurring memberships, subscription boxes, or regular client billing, Square’s basic recurring tools can feel restrictive. You often need robust customer profiles, automated card-on-file updater tools, and seamless synchronization between physical checkouts and recurring customer portals.

The top alternatives to Square for brick-and-mortar subscription management depend on whether you prioritize robust retail inventory, deep omnichannel syncing, or lower processing costs:

• Shopify POS — Best for Omnichannel Subscriptions. If you sell both in-store and online, Shopify POS paired with apps like Shopify Subscriptions or integrations with tools like Recurly or Chargebee allows you to manage recurring physical boxes or in-store memberships seamlessly. Customer billing profiles sync across your physical register and digital storefront, making it easy for members to manage their plans online or in person.
• Helcim — Best for Low-Cost Processing & Built-In Recurring Billing. Helcim is widely praised for offering transparent interchange-plus pricing with no monthly software subscription fees for its POS. It features a robust virtual terminal and built-in recurring payment tools that let you set up structured memberships, recurring invoices, or payment plans for in-person and on-file clients while significantly lowering your transaction overhead.
• Stax — Best for High-Volume Established Stores. Stax operates on a flat monthly subscription model rather than marking up every transaction with a percentage fee. This makes it exceptionally cost-effective for high-volume brick-and-mortar merchants processing massive monthly totals in recurring memberships or club fees. It includes powerful analytics, invoicing, and advanced recurring billing architecture.
• Clover POS — Best for Hardware and Merchant Flexibility. Clover offers native recurring payment capabilities through its dashboard, allowing you to schedule automated customer billing on file. Unlike Square, Clover allows you to shop around for independent merchant processors (depending on the reseller you choose), giving you more leverage to negotiate lower overall transaction rates for your physical store.
• Lightspeed Retail — Best for Complex Inventory-Heavy Stores. If your subscription model involves heavy product curation (like wine clubs, specialty foods, or boutique retail boxes), Lightspeed Retail offers superior inventory management and detailed purchasing analytics that easily outpace Square's basic tracking as your catalog scales.

To help narrow down the best fit, tell me:

• What kind of products or services are you subscribing your customers to?
• What is your estimated monthly processing volume?
• Do you also run an e-commerce store , or is it strictly in-person?

For a brick-and-mortar business that needs subscription management (memberships, recurring services, classes, clubs, retainers, recurring products, etc.), the best Square alternatives depend on whether you need a stronger POS, a dedicated subscription engine, or better customer/member management. Square itself already supports recurring subscriptions, plans, trials, recurring billing intervals, and payment updates, so the main reason to switch is usually workflow depth rather than basic billing.

My shortlist by business type

Gym / fitness studio

• Mindbody, GymMaster, or similar membership-first systems usually outperform Square because subscriptions are the core workflow.
• Look for: freezes/holds, upgrades, family plans, attendance tracking, failed-payment recovery.

Salon / spa / wellness

• Vagaro or Mindbody-style platforms tend to fit better.
• Look for: memberships + appointments + packages + client history.

Retail store with a subscription club

• Lightspeed, Shopify POS, or Clover may be stronger because the subscription is connected to inventory and customer purchases.

Coffee shop / food business with recurring customers

• Square is often still competitive unless you need advanced memberships, loyalty tiers, or a separate CRM.

Custom membership model

• Stripe Billing is usually the most flexible option, especially for unusual rules (usage-based billing, add-ons, credits, prorations).

A few questions would narrow this down significantly:

1. What kind of brick-and-mortar business is it (gym, salon, retail, service, club, etc.)?
2. Are subscriptions access memberships (monthly dues) or recurring purchases (products/services)?
3. Do you need a full POS replacement, or just a better subscription layer that works alongside your POS?

If you mean a physical retail/service business where customers sign up in-store and then get charged automatically, I’d narrow the Square alternatives to these:

1. Clover — closest overall Square alternative

Clover is probably the first one I'd demo if you want one system at the counter. Its current retail offering supports recurring schedules/invoices alongside normal POS payments, and Clover also has APIs specifically for creating recurring payment plans and subscriptions.

Good fit if: customers walk into a store, enroll in a monthly plan, and you want the employee to manage the customer/subscription without building software.

Watch out for: Clover's ecosystem can be more fragmented than Square's, depending on your processor, reseller, and apps.

2. Stripe — best if subscriptions are the important part

Stripe is the strongest choice if your subscription logic is more complicated than "charge $29/month." It supports trials, prorations, discounts, upgrades/downgrades, customer self-service, failed-payment recovery, subscription schedules, and recurring billing. Crucially for your use case, Stripe explicitly supports signing up subscribers through POS and tokenizing their payment details for recurring charges, using Stripe Terminal.

The downside is that Stripe is not a turnkey retail POS like Square. You generally build or assemble the in-store experience around Terminal, Billing, and potentially another POS/inventory system.

Good fit if: subscription management is strategically important and you're willing to use a more modular stack.

3. Lightspeed — excellent retail POS, but I'd be cautious

Lightspeed historically had a very good subscription feature integrated into Retail + Lightspeed Payments. However, its current documentation says Lightspeed Subscriptions is no longer available as a new add-on; existing merchants can continue using it.

So I wouldn't choose Lightspeed specifically because you need subscriptions unless their sales team confirms a current solution for your exact setup.

4. Vagaro — sleeper pick for membership businesses

If your "brick-and-mortar" business is something like a salon, spa, gym, yoga studio, fitness business, tanning shop, or wellness business, I'd move Vagaro much higher on the list. Those businesses need more than recurring card charges—they need memberships, customer profiles, appointments, packages, staff, check-in, and POS.

5. Mindbody — for larger membership/fitness operations

Similar idea, but more oriented toward established fitness/wellness businesses and larger operations. It's worth considering if your "subscription" is really a membership relationship rather than simply recurring billing.

---

What I'd choose

If you're replacing Square and want the least disruption: → Clover

If you want the best subscription engine: → Stripe Billing + Stripe Terminal

If you're a retail store with sophisticated inventory/POS needs: → Lightspeed, but verify the subscription functionality first.

If you're a gym/salon/spa/studio: → Vagaro or Mindbody

One important distinction: subscription billing ≠ membership management. If you need things like "this customer gets 2 visits/month, can freeze their membership, gets 10% off purchases, can upgrade plans, and employees need to see their active status at checkout," I'd evaluate these quite differently than if you simply need to charge a card $49.99 every month.

If you tell me what kind of brick-and-mortar business you run, number of locations, approximate subscribers, and whether subscriptions include physical products/services, I can give you a much tighter top 3 with estimated costs and migration difficulty.

When managing subscriptions for a brick-and-mortar storefront (such as a local coffee bean club, a retail box curation service, or a hybrid in-person/online membership model), you need a system that handles card-on-file tokenization securely, manages recurring billing cycles automatically, and offers a robust in-store POS.

The top alternatives to Square for physical retail subscription management vary based on your specific operational focus:

• Shopify POS — Best for omnichannel/hybrid retail. If you have a physical shopfront and want a seamless transition to or from an online store, Shopify handles native retail hardware and integrates with powerful subscription apps (like Smartrr or Recharge). This allows in-person customers to manage their digital accounts, swap items, or skip a month seamlessly.
• Clover — Best for hardware flexibility and merchant accounts. Unlike Square (which locks you into its single ecosystem and aggregated account), Clover offers versatile countertop and mobile hardware paired with a wide marketplace of third-party apps for recurring billing and customer loyalty. It also lets you shop around for different merchant processors to secure lower rates as your volume scales.
• Lightspeed Retail — Best for inventory-heavy businesses. If your subscriptions involve physical goods with complex variant matrices, purchase orders, or multi-location stock tracking, Lightspeed outclasses Square. It features robust customer management tools that can be tied to recurring local memberships or repeat fulfillment workflows.
• Helcim — Best for low-cost, high-volume processing. If you dislike Square's flat-rate processing fees—which become expensive once you process over $10K to $15K a month—Helcim offers true interchange-plus pricing with automatic volume discounts. Their virtual terminal and saved customer card features make managing manual or recurring local billing straightforward without heavy monthly software overhead.

To help narrow down the ideal platform, tell me:

• What kind of products or services are you offering in your subscriptions?
• What is your estimated monthly processing volume?
• Do you also sell (or plan to sell) online alongside your physical store?

Managing recurring revenue and subscriptions in a physical, brick-and-mortar setting requires a point-of-sale (POS) system that bridges in-person customer sign-ups with automated, tokenized card-on-file billing . While Square works well for basic setups, growing brick-and-mortar operations often outgrow its reporting or need deeper native subscription features.

The top alternatives to Square for brick-and-mortar subscription and recurring billing management include:

• Clover POS
  • Best For: Retailers and service businesses wanting robust, robust hardware and native recurring billing.
  • How it handles subscriptions: Clover includes built-in recurring payment tools and invoice management across most of its service plans. You can securely save customer cards-on-file (tokenized for PCI compliance), set weekly, monthly, or annual billing intervals, and pull specialized apps from the Clover App Market for advanced tier-based memberships.
• Lightspeed Retail (R-Series / S-Series)
  • Best For: Complex retail inventories and structured membership/subscription boxes.
  • How it handles subscriptions: Lightspeed features native subscription management designed to automate recurring monthly billing, package fees, and recurring product shipments directly out of the POS. It handles automatic credit card updates if a member's card expires, syncs multi-location stock levels, and integrates seamlessly with omnichannel loyalty programs. You can explore their offerings directly on the Lightspeed Retail POS platform.
• Shopify POS
  • Best For: Omnichannel stores that sell online and want a physical storefront presence.
  • How it handles subscriptions: While known for e-commerce, Shopify POS syncs fluidly with the Shopify App Store subscription extensions. Customers can sign up or get billed on a recurring schedule, and the inventory automatically updates whether a transaction occurs online or at the physical cash wrap.
• Helcim
  • Best For: Cost-conscious merchants wanting transparent interchange-plus pricing.
  • How it handles subscriptions: Helcim offers free POS software that includes built-in recurring payment tools and customer management features. Because they use interchange-plus pricing instead of flat rates, high-volume subscription businesses can save significantly on processing fees. You can learn more via the Helcim POS Software site.

To help narrow down the ideal platform, could you share:

• What type of physical business you run (e.g., retail boutique, gym/fitness studio, or specialty food/wine club)?
• Roughly how many active subscribers you manage or expect to launch with?

If by “subscription management” you mean recurring memberships/payments sold at a physical storefront, I’d shortlist these over Square:

1. Clover — best Square replacement

Clover is probably the closest fit if you want physical checkout + customer profiles + recurring payments without building a system yourself. Clover specifically supports recurring membership payments for gyms and similar businesses.

Good for: gyms, clubs, salons, studios, specialty shops, recurring service businesses.

The big advantage is that recurring billing can live alongside your normal POS rather than requiring a completely separate payments stack.

2. Shopify POS + Shopify Subscriptions — best if you also sell online

This has become substantially more interesting for brick-and-mortar. As of October 2025, Shopify added the ability to sell subscriptions directly through Shopify POS, so employees can enroll customers in recurring purchases right at the physical checkout.

Shopify also has a large ecosystem of subscription/membership apps; its App Store currently lists more than 100 subscription apps, including membership-focused options.

Good for: retail stores, coffee/food subscriptions, consumables, subscription boxes, loyalty/membership programs.

One caveat: Shopify POS Pro is currently listed at $89/month per location, so it's not necessarily the cheapest Square migration.

3. Stripe Billing + Stripe Terminal — best if subscriptions are the core business

If your priority is sophisticated recurring billing rather than having everything inside a single POS, I'd seriously consider Stripe.

You can have:

In-store checkout → Stripe Terminal
Recurring membership → Stripe Billing
Customer/payment data → Stripe
Website/app → Stripe APIs

This is considerably more flexible than Square, particularly if you need things like different billing intervals, trials, prorations, upgrades/downgrades, automated failed-payment recovery, or custom membership logic.

The downside is that it's more of a payments infrastructure platform than an out-of-the-box retail POS.

4. Lightspeed Retail — good retail POS, but I'd be cautious

Lightspeed does have a subscription feature designed for recurring monthly billing and memberships. However, there's an important 2026 caveat: Lightspeed says Subscriptions is no longer available as a new add-on; existing merchants can continue using it.

So I wouldn't choose Lightspeed today specifically because you need native subscription management.

It remains attractive if sophisticated inventory, purchasing, multi-location retail, and reporting are your primary requirements.

5. Heartland Retail — worth a look for traditional retail

Heartland combines retail POS, payments, customer management, loyalty, inventory, and multi-location capabilities. Its current retail pricing starts at $89/month.

I'd put it behind Clover/Shopify for a subscription-centric business because its subscription capabilities aren't as compelling as those platforms' dedicated recurring-payment options.

---

My ranking

If I were choosing specifically for brick-and-mortar + recurring subscriptions, I'd go:

🥇 Clover — easiest Square-style replacement with recurring memberships
🥈 Shopify POS + Subscriptions — best if you have an online store too
🥉 Stripe Billing + Terminal — best if subscription complexity/customization matters most
4. Heartland — solid traditional retail alternative
5. Lightspeed — excellent retail POS, but I wouldn't select it for new subscription functionality

One important distinction: if you're talking about memberships (e.g. $50/month for unlimited services/discounts/access), rather than product subscriptions (e.g. automatically selling a $20 product every month), the ranking changes considerably.

If you tell me what kind of brick-and-mortar business you have and roughly how many subscribers/locations you have, I can narrow this down to the 2–3 best options and compare monthly fees, payment processing, recurring billing, failed-payment handling, POS integration, and migration from Square.

While Square is great for simple card-on-file billing , its flat-rate subscription fees can get expensive, and it lacks advanced membership tiers, automated retries for failed payments, or robust brick-and-mortar contract management.

The top alternatives to Square for physical, brick-and-mortar storefronts managing recurring memberships or physical product subscriptions include the following options:

• Shopify POS is the gold standard if you operate a hybrid model (physical brick-and-mortar + robust e-commerce). Through Shopify's App Store , you can integrate powerful native or third-party recurring subscription apps that sync customer profiles, automatically charge credit cards on file, and apply member-only discounts seamlessly at your physical counter register.
• Lightspeed Retail is built for high-inventory, complex, or multi-location brick-and-mortar shops. It excels at deep data tracking and supports customer loyalty and recurring profile structures via integrated partners, making it ideal if your subscriptions involve heavy physical inventory management (like a boutique box or wine club).
• Clover POS offers unmatched hardware flexibility (from mobile Go devices to full station registers) and a massive app market. By using specialized recurring billing and membership apps from the Clover App Market , you get a dedicated physical terminal experience paired with processor flexibility rather than being locked into a single ecosystem.
• Helcim is the best low-cost alternative if you want to escape flat-rate pricing. It uses true interchange-plus pricing (which is significantly cheaper for high-volume or high-ticket recurring billing) and includes built-in recurring payment tools and customer management without monthly software subscription costs for the basics.

To help narrow down the ideal platform, tell me:

• What type of subscription do you run (e.g., physical box club, gym/studio membership, recurring retail rentals)?
• Do you also sell online , or is it 100% in-store?

If your business depends on in-person sales plus recurring memberships or subscriptions, the best alternative depends on whether subscriptions are your core business or just one feature.

Here's how the strongest options compare:

If you're a retailer with memberships

I'd look at Lightspeed first. It offers much deeper inventory, reporting, and multi-location capabilities than Square, while supporting recurring revenue through integrations and customer management. It's frequently recommended for retailers who've outgrown Square.

If memberships are your business

If customers primarily pay monthly (gyms, makerspaces, clubs, studios, coworking, etc.), consider separating the subscription engine from the POS:

• Stripe Billing handles recurring payments, failed-payment retries, prorations, and customer portals.
• Pair it with specialized membership software such as:
  • MemberPress (if your website runs on WordPress)

This approach is commonly recommended by organizations that found Square's subscription features limiting.

If you want an all-in-one replacement

Clover is worth considering because it has a large app marketplace. You can add recurring billing, loyalty, scheduling, and membership features without replacing the entire POS, making it attractive if you want flexibility as your business grows.

If you also sell online

Shopify POS is one of the strongest options if your physical store and ecommerce business are equally important. Subscription apps integrate directly with Shopify, and inventory stays synchronized across online and in-store sales.

My recommendations by business type

• Retail store with VIP/member pricing: Lightspeed
• Gym, martial arts, yoga, dance: Mindbody or Zenoti
• Salon or spa: Vagaro or Zenoti
• Coworking or makerspace: Stripe + Join It
• Retail with significant online sales: Shopify POS
• Need processor flexibility and customizable hardware: Clover

If you can share what type of brick-and-mortar business you run (retail, gym, salon, makerspace, coffee shop, etc.) and approximately how many active subscribers or members you have, I can narrow it down to the two or three platforms that are likely to fit best.