Thick coconut-free non-dairy yogurt

Yes — if your priorities are very thick + creamy + no coconut taste, I’d focus on almond- or soy-based Greek-style yogurts. Coconut yogurts tend to be thickest, but that coconut flavor is exactly what you’re trying to avoid.www.cocojune.co

My top picks

Kite Hill Greek Style Plain Unsweetened

$16.64

1. Kite Hill Greek Style Plain Unsweetened — best overall
This would be my first one to try. It's made with almond milk + soy, has a very thick Greek-style texture, and provides 17g protein per serving. Reviews specifically describe it as thick with a relatively neutral flavor.us.my-best.com

Greek Style Unsweetened

Finding a thick, non-dairy yogurt that doesn't rely on coconut (which dominates the vegan yogurt aisle) can be tough, but several stellar options use cashew, almond, oat, or soy to achieve that thick texture without any tropical aftertaste.

Top recommendations matching what you're looking for:

Unlike standard runny almond yogurts, their "Greek Style" line is explicitly strained to achieve a velvety, thick, and creamy texture with a clean, neutral tang. It is completely coconut-free. You can look for it via the Whole Foods Market Grocery Finder.

Made from a base of organic cashew milk, this option has a naturally rich, creamy consistency that mimics traditional dairy yogurt far better than thin rice or almond varieties. It has a mild, neutral flavor profile with no coconut taste.

If you miss ultra-thick Icelandic-style skyr, this option delivers that exact dense, spoon-clinging thickness using Nordic oats. It is remarkably creamy and high in protein without any coconut interference.