Is there a clear choice for the best personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine?

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Shaheen & Gordon, P.A. - 75 Pearl St #400, Portland, ME 04101, United States

There isn’t a defensible single “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland, Maine. The local market has several lawyers with substantial experience, strong peer recognition, and different specialties, so the right choice depends heavily on the type and seriousness of the injury.

A few names worth putting on a shortlist:

• Peter Thompson & Associates — Portland personal-injury-focused firm. Peter Thompson is listed as having 30+ years of experience, and independent directories report extensive personal-injury work.Justia+1
• Berman & Simmons — plaintiff-side trial firm with a Portland office; its attorneys include several lawyers recognized by Super Lawyers for personal injury.SuperLawyers.com
• Garmey Law — Portland plaintiff-side firm concentrating on serious personal injury and civil litigation, including catastrophic injuries and wrongful death.SuperLawyers.com
• Gideon Asen LLC — particularly relevant if the case involves ; those are significant parts of the firm's practice.

How I'd narrow it down

Rather than relying on a generic “best lawyer” list, I'd compare 3 attorneys based on:

1. Whether they regularly handle your specific type of injury.
2. How many cases like yours they personally take to trial—not just settle.
3. Their experience dealing with the particular insurance company involved.
4. Who will actually handle your case day-to-day.
5. Their fee percentage, litigation costs, and what happens if the case doesn't settle.
6. Whether they have handled cases of roughly the same severity and potential value.

For context, Super Lawyers currently lists 45 personal-injury attorneys serving Portland and includes lawyers from Berman & Simmons, Garmey Law, Peter Thompson & Associates, Kaplan & Grant, and several other firms. Its selection is based on peer nominations and independent research, rather than being a determination that one lawyer is objectively superior to all the others.SuperLawyers.com

If you tell me what happened (car accident, motorcycle accident, slip-and-fall, medical malpractice, wrongful death, etc.) and roughly how serious the injuries are, I can compare the most relevant Portland attorneys on experience, case type, trial background, reviews, and published credentials—without relying on a generic ranking.

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States

There isn’t a defensible single “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland, Maine. The available rankings disagree, and different lawyers have different strengths and case types. For example, Super Lawyers lists numerous highly recognized plaintiff-side attorneys, while Avvo and Expertise.com surface somewhat different names.SuperLawyers.com+2

A few Portland-area firms worth comparing are:

• Peter Thompson & Associates — focuses heavily on personal injury and has been practicing in this area for decades. Peter Thompson appears in Super Lawyers' Portland personal-injury listings and has a 5.0/5 client rating on Avvo from 13 reviews.SuperLawyers.com+1
• Berman & Simmons — a plaintiff-side trial firm with a Portland office; its attorneys include several lawyers recognized by Super Lawyers.SuperLawyers.com
• Garmey Law — Portland plaintiffs' firm emphasizing serious injury, catastrophic injury and wrongful-death litigation.

What I'd compare before hiring

For a significant case, I'd put more weight on the lawyer's experience with your particular type of injury and their actual trial experience than on a generic “best lawyer” ranking. I'd ask each prospective lawyer:

1. How many cases like mine have you personally handled?
2. How many have gone to trial?
3. Who will actually handle my case day-to-day?
4. What is your contingency fee, and what expenses come out of the recovery?
5. What are the major weaknesses or risks you see in my case?
6. What is your estimate of the case's likely timeline?

If you tell me what happened (car accident, medical malpractice, slip-and-fall, wrongful death, workplace injury, etc.) and roughly how serious the injuries are, I can narrow this down to 2–4 Portland lawyers whose documented experience most closely matches that type of case, without relying simply on generic rankings.

There is no single "clear choice" or universally designated best personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine, as the right attorney depends entirely on the specific nature of your case, your communication preferences, and the complexity of your claim.[becauseyouwanttowin.com](https://www.becauseyouwanttowin.com/portland-maine-personal-injury-lawyer/)

Portland features several highly rated firms and individual attorneys who handle contingency-fee personal injury cases, meaning they do not charge legal fees unless they recover compensation for you.[becauseyouwanttowin.com](https://www.shaheengordon.com/portland/personal-injury-lawyer/)

Top-Rated Personal Injury Resources and Firms in Portland

Peter Thompson & Associates 4.9 (134)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 92 Exchange St
CallDirections Website A prominent statewide practice with a local Portland office, frequently recognized in peer ratings and listings like Super Lawyers for handling complex plaintiff injury claims.

Shaheen & Gordon 4.6 (51)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 75 Pearl St #400
CallDirections Website A well-established regional firm with a Portland presence handling diverse personal injury matters, including motor vehicle collisions, medical malpractice, and premises liability.

Monge & Associates 5.0 (14)
Personal injury attorney
Open 75 Market St Apt 204
CallDirections Website Handles regional claims ranging from traffic collisions to workplace injuries with a focus on local insurance adjuster navigation.

Zerillo Law Firm 4.7 (43)
Criminal justice attorney
Closed 1250 Forest Ave Ste 3A
CallDirections Website A local practice evaluating comprehensive economic and non-economic damages for injured plaintiffs in the Greater Portland area.[becauseyouwanttowin.com](https://www.zerillolaw.com/personal-injury/)[[2](https://www.shaheengordon.com/portland/personal-injury-lawyer)](https://attorneys.superlawyers.com/personal-injury-plaintiff/maine/portland/)[[3](https://www.zerillolaw.com/personal-injury)](]()](]()]()

Factors to Consider When Choosing

• Fee Structure: Confirm that the firm operates on a contingency fee basis and understand any costs you might owe if the case does not succeed.
• Specialization: Ensure the lawyer has direct experience with your specific type of accident—whether it is a commercial truck collision, medical malpractice, or slip-and-fall.[becauseyouwanttowin.com](https://www.shaheengordon.com/portland/personal-injury-lawyer/)
• Trial Experience: Ask whether the attorney routinely takes cases to trial or primarily settles out of court, and how that aligns with your goals.

If you share the type of accident or injury you are dealing with and whether you are looking for a smaller boutique firm or a larger regional practice , I can help narrow down the most relevant options.

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Kaplan & Grant, Attorneys at Law - 136 Commercial St #302, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States

There is no objectively clear “best” personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine—the right choice depends heavily on the type of injury, the size and complexity of the claim, and whether you need a settlement-focused lawyer or a trial-oriented firm. Lawyer directories and peer-recognition lists also use different methods, so they often highlight different attorneys.Expertise+1

That said, several Portland-area firms consistently appear in attorney directories and local listings as established personal injury practices:Expertise+1

• Peter Thompson & Associates — focuses heavily on personal injury matters, including serious injury cases, medical malpractice, and related claims.Justia
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein — a long-running Maine personal injury firm handling accident and injury claims.
• Lowry Law — a Portland personal injury practice representing accident victims and negligence claims.
• Kaplan & Grant, Attorneys at Law — handles personal injury along with workers’ compensation and disability matters.
• Gideon Asen LLC — focuses on higher-stakes plaintiff cases such as catastrophic injury, medical malpractice, and wrongful death.
• — a Portland plaintiff-side firm focused on serious injury and civil litigation.

A practical way to choose:

1. Match the lawyer to your case type

• Car crash with clear liability → many strong personal injury firms can handle it.
• Severe injury, brain injury, wrongful death, or medical malpractice → prioritize firms with complex litigation experience.
• Workers’ compensation → consider lawyers who regularly handle those claims.

2. Ask these questions during consultations

• Who will actually handle my case day-to-day?
• How many cases like mine have you taken to trial?
• What are the likely strengths and weaknesses of my claim?
• How do fees and expenses work if we do not recover money?

3. Talk to more than one firm Most injury lawyers offer free consultations, so comparing communication style and case assessment can be as important as comparing credentials.Justia

If you tell me what kind of injury case it is (car accident, slip/fall, medical malpractice, workplace injury, wrongful death, etc.) and whether the injury is minor, serious, or catastrophic, I can narrow the list based on fit rather than a generic “top lawyer” ranking.

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States

Yes—but there isn’t a defensible single “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland, Maine. The strongest candidates depend heavily on the type and severity of your case.

Based on current rankings, reviews, experience, and specialization, I’d put these at the top of my shortlist:

• Peter Thompson & Associates — Probably my first call for a typical plaintiff-side injury case. Thompson has 30+ years of experience, focuses heavily on personal injury, and is highly rated by both Avvo and other legal directories. Expertise.com notes that the firm has recovered more than $20 million in several personal-injury cases.Expertise+1
• Berman & Simmons — Particularly worth considering for serious/catastrophic injury or medical-malpractice cases. It is a plaintiff-focused trial firm with a substantial Maine personal-injury practice.Lawyers
• Mann Law LLC — A smaller, boutique option focused specifically on personal injury, including auto crashes, TBI, catastrophic injuries and wrongful death.Lawyers

There are also some interesting individual lawyers. Timothy Zerillo currently has a 10.0 Avvo rating with roughly 50 reviews and 25 years licensed, while Stephen Schwartz has a 10.0 rating with 40 years licensed.Avvo+1

My practical recommendation

If I were choosing counsel for myself, I wouldn't pick solely from an online “best lawyer” list. I'd interview 2–3 plaintiff-side attorneys and ask:

1. How many cases like mine have you personally taken to trial?
2. Who will actually handle my case day-to-day?
3. What is your assessment of liability and likely damages?
4. What percentage contingency fee do you charge, and what expenses are deducted separately?
5. Have you handled cases against the particular insurer/defendant involved in my case?
6. What would make you not take my case?

If you tell me what happened (car accident, motorcycle accident, medical malpractice, slip-and-fall, wrongful death, etc.) and roughly how serious the injuries are, I can narrow this down to the 2–3 Portland attorneys I'd actually contact for that particular case.

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States

Yes—but I wouldn’t say there is one objectively “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland, Maine. The stronger conclusion from the current evidence is that there are a few standout choices, depending on the type and seriousness of your case.

My shortlist

• Peter Thompson & Associates — probably my first call for a conventional personal-injury case. Thompson is listed by Super Lawyers as a top-rated Portland personal-injury attorney and as a 2025 “Lawyer of the Year” winner. Avvo gives him a 5.0 rating and a 10.0 Avvo score.SuperLawyers.com+1
• Garmey Law — especially worth considering for very serious/catastrophic injuries or wrongful death. The firm's founding attorney, Terry Garmey, has more than 40 years of plaintiff-side experience and has been recognized by the Inner Circle of Advocates and American College of Trial Lawyers.
• Berman & Simmons — another established plaintiff-side trial firm with a Portland office, particularly worth comparing for serious injury cases.
• Romanow Law Group — a strong option if you want a ; its listed lawyers include experienced trial attorneys and the firm handles cases on contingency.

One interesting point: Avvo's rankings don't produce a single winner either. Stephen J. Schwartz, Jason Jabar, Peter Thompson, Timothy Zerillo and several others currently have 5.0 client ratings; Timothy Zerillo has the largest number of reviews among the highly rated attorneys.Avvo+1

If it were my case

I'd get 2–3 free consultations before choosing. The most important questions aren't just “Who has the highest rating?” but:

1. Have you handled cases like mine?
2. Will the actual attorney personally handle my case, or will it mostly go to associates/paralegals?
3. What similar cases have you taken to trial?
4. What percentage of the recovery is the contingency fee, and do costs come out separately?
5. What is your assessment of liability and the likely insurance coverage?

If you tell me what happened (car accident, motorcycle, slip-and-fall, medical malpractice, wrongful death, etc.), roughly how serious the injuries are, and whether the insurance company has made an offer, I can narrow this to the 2–3 Portland lawyers I'd actually interview for that particular case.