Parse
IndexPricing
Sign in
  1. Research
Research
Local AI search: why ChatGPT and Google disagree on 83% of #1 local businesses

Local AI search: why ChatGPT and Google disagree on 83% of #1 local businesses

Published Nov 20, 2026

On this page
  • #1 agreement
  • Listing cards
  • Geographic drift
  • Drift by city
  • Borough effect
  • City winners
  • Footprint tiers
  • Single-engine winners
  • What to do
  • Study scope
  • How we measured
  • More like this
  • #1 agreement
  • Listing cards
  • Geographic drift
  • Drift by city
  • Borough effect
  • City winners
  • Footprint tiers
  • Single-engine winners
  • What to do
  • Study scope
  • How we measured
  • More like this

Dimitry ApollonskyFounder, Parse

DataWhat reviewed means

When buyers ask AI engines for a local business, do ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode recommend the same local winners, keep answers inside the right city, and favor national chains over single-city operators?

We analyzed 17,121 parsed local business listings across 5,666 local answers and 12,380 geographic place-drift checks on ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode from August 1 through November 19, 2026, including 2,549 matched local prompts and 22 city-market leaderboards on November 19, 2026.

Across 17,121 parsed local business listings, 12,380 geographic place-drift checks, and 22 city-market leaderboards, ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode agreed on the #1 local business just 17.2% of the time.

ChatGPT and Google agree on the #1 local business just 17.2% of the time

National category queries already split across AI engines, where ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode agree on the top brand 36.2% of the time. Local recommendations fracture twice as hard. Across 2,549 matched local questions answered by both engines, 623 returned parsed local listings on both sides and 511 named a resolved #1 local business on both.

In those 511 head-to-head local matchups, ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode picked the same #1 business only 88 times, or 17.2%. Across the full shortlist, the two engines averaged just 0.56 shared local businesses per answer, even though ChatGPT Search averaged 2.86 resolved local brands per answer and Google AI Mode averaged 2.16.

#1 local agreement across engines
17.2%

88 of 511 matched local prompts

0.56 shared local businesses per answer

Listings with a street address
97.5% vs 34.7%

ChatGPT Search (97.5%) vs Google AI Mode (34.7%)

Google names neighborhoods on 46.1% vs ChatGPT's 2.5%

ChatGPT drift on placeless prompts
11.06%

134 of 1,212 answers drifted to another city

Up to 28.6% in London Westminster and 18.5% in Brooklyn

Local listing share held by 20+ city chains
2.6%

334 of 12,876 resolved local listings

Independent operators hold or share #1 in 14 of 17 Pest Control cities

17.2%
of matched local prompts got the same #1 business on ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode
88 of 511 matched pairs with resolved #1 listings; 0.56 shared brands per answer

Takeaway

Winning #1 locally on Google AI Mode does not carry over to ChatGPT Search. Nearly 83% of the time, the two engines hand the top local spot to different businesses.

ChatGPT builds numbered street-address blocks; Google builds neighborhood place cards

Each engine formats local recommendations from a different structural template. Across 8,199 listings in 2,415 ChatGPT Search answers, ChatGPT outputs numbered text blocks averaging 3.40 listings per answer across 1,258 distinct brands. Street addresses appear on 97.5% of ChatGPT rows, while neighborhood names appear on just 2.5%.

Across 8,922 listings in 3,251 Google AI Mode answers, Google renders compact place cards averaging 2.74 listings per answer across a wider pool of 1,804 distinct brands. Only 34.7% of Google rows print a street address, while 46.1% attach a neighborhood label. Brand identity resolution is similar on both engines: 73.5% on ChatGPT Search and 77.1% on Google AI Mode.

Local listing metadata rate, by engine

  • ChatGPT Search
  • Google AI Mode
  • Street address shown
  • ChatGPT Search97.5%
  • Google AI Mode34.7%
  • Neighborhood named
  • ChatGPT Search2.5%
  • Google AI Mode46.1%
  • Brand resolved
  • ChatGPT Search73.5%
  • Google AI Mode77.1%
  • 0%50%100%
August 1 through November 19, 2026. 8,199 numbered-block listings across 2,415 ChatGPT Search answers; 8,922 place-card listings across 3,251 Google AI Mode answers.

Takeaway

ChatGPT anchors local answers to verifiable street addresses, while Google leans on neighborhood tags and place cards.

Omitting the city doubles ChatGPT geographic drift to 11.06%

To test whether AI recommendations stay inside the intended city, we measured geographic drift across 12,380 local answers. When prompts named the target city directly, drift stayed low and nearly identical on both engines: 4.47% on ChatGPT Search (238 of 5,327 answers) and 4.71% on Google AI Mode (264 of 5,601 answers).

When prompts dropped the city name and relied on a local business's home-city context, ChatGPT Search drifted to another city in 11.06% of answers (134 of 1,212), more than double its placed rate and more than double Google AI Mode's 5.42% placeless drift (13 of 240).

Geographic drift rate by prompt mode and engine

  • ChatGPT Search
  • Google AI Mode
  • City named in prompt
  • ChatGPT Search4.47%238 of 5,327
  • Google AI Mode4.71%264 of 5,601
  • Placeless local prompt
  • ChatGPT Search11.06%134 of 1,212
  • Google AI Mode5.42%13 of 240
  • 0%5%10%15%
12,380 geographic place-drift checks (August 1 through November 19, 2026). City named vs placeless local prompt.

Takeaway

Leaving the city out of a local prompt causes more than one in ten ChatGPT answers to drift into a different municipality.

Dense boroughs and Las Vegas suburbs suffer the highest drift rates

Geographic drift concentrates in two environments: dense multi-borough cities tested without a city name, and smaller suburbs orbiting a famous metro anchor. In London Westminster, placeless prompts drifted 28.6% of the time (20 of 70 answers). Placeless Brooklyn prompts drifted 18.5% (63 of 341), and placeless Las Vegas prompts drifted 13.8% (22 of 160).

Even when buyers named the exact suburb around Las Vegas, answers regularly collapsed back into Las Vegas proper. Explicitly named prompts still drifted 12.4% in Sunrise Manor, 12.3% in Nellis Air Force Base, 10.9% in Summerlin South, 9.9% in Calico Basin, and 9.4% in Winchester. By contrast, explicitly named New York, NY (0 of 623) and Brooklyn, NY (0 of 616) had 0.0% drift.

Geographic drift across 20 tested places and prompt modes

Drift (%) ยท Top 10 of 20

  • London, Westminster ยท Placeless28.6%
  • Brooklyn, NY ยท Placeless18.5%
  • Las Vegas, NV ยท Placeless13.8%
  • Sunrise Manor, NV ยท City named12.4%
  • Nellis Air Force Base, NV ยท City named12.3%
  • Summerlin South, NV ยท City named10.9%
  • Calico Basin, NV ยท City named9.9%
  • Winchester, NV ยท City named9.4%
  • Dubai ยท Placeless9.2%
  • North Las Vegas, NV ยท City named8.4%
  • 0%10%20%30%
Explore the data (20 rows)
London, WestminsterPlaceless702028.6
Brooklyn, NYPlaceless3416318.5
Las Vegas, NVPlaceless1602213.8
Sunrise Manor, NVCity named2102612.4
Nellis Air Force Base, NVCity named2112612.3
Summerlin South, NVCity named2112310.9
Calico Basin, NVCity named212219.9
Winchester, NVCity named212209.4
DubaiPlaceless6569.2
North Las Vegas, NVCity named214188.4
Spring Valley, NVCity named212115.2
Paradise, NVCity named216115.1
Whitney, NVCity named215104.7
Ghaziabad, Uttar PradeshCity named14042.9
Henderson, NVCity named21452.3
Business Bay, Dubai EmirateCity named5411.9
Enterprise, NVCity named21331.4
TexasCity named7011.4
Brooklyn, NYCity named61600
New York, NYCity named62300
Deduplicated place-level drift evaluations (August 1 through November 19, 2026). Sort by drift rate or total answers, or switch to Chart view.

Takeaway

Suburbs next to a dominant metro hub lose local containment even when buyers spell out the suburb's exact name.

Naming the borough cuts Brooklyn drift from 18.5% down to 0.0%

Brooklyn illustrates how strongly prompt phrasing controls local containment. When prompts omitted the location, 63 of 341 answers drifted outside Brooklyn (18.5%). When prompts explicitly named Brooklyn, 0 of 616 answers drifted (0.0%).

Not every suburb enjoys that fix. Henderson, NV kept drift low at 2.3% (5 of 214) and Enterprise, NV sat at 1.4% (3 of 213), while adjacent unincorporated communities like Sunrise Manor (12.4%) and Summerlin South (10.9%) continued spilling into central Las Vegas listings even when named explicitly.

Brooklyn drift when city is omitted
18.5%

63 of 341 placeless answers

Drops to 0.0% (0 of 616) when Brooklyn is named

New York, NY drift when named
0.0%

0 of 623 explicitly placed answers

Major city anchors hold strict boundaries

London Westminster placeless drift
28.6%

20 of 70 answers drifted outside the borough

Highest drift rate in the 20-place sample

Takeaway

Major boroughs lock down cleanly once named in the prompt, while unincorporated suburbs still pull central-metro results.

Independent operators hold or share #1 in 14 of 17 Pest Control cities

Across 22 daily city-market leaderboards measured on November 19, 2026, national household brands rarely owned the local #1 rank. In Pest Control Services across 17 Oklahoma and New York locations, independent local and regional operators ranked #1 outright in 13 markets and tied for #1 in a 14th (14 of 17, or 82.4%). National chains led outright in three: Terminix in Nassau County, NY (53.8%) and Roslyn Harbor, NY (35.7%), and Orkin in Muskogee, OK (53.3%), with Orkin also tying West Termite, Pest & Lawn in Summit, OK (28.6%).

Adjacent towns inside the exact same metro area routinely crowned different #1 winners. On Long Island, Terminix led Nassau County overall (53.8%) and Roslyn Harbor (35.7%), while Colony Pest Management, Inc. led New Hyde Park (73.3%), Parkway Pest Services led North Hempstead (53.3%), Fox Pest Control led Old Westbury (46.2%), and Joroba Pest Corp led Hempstead (33.3%). In Home Staging Furniture Rental Services across five New York and New Jersey cities, Quadra Furniture & Spaces led three New Jersey cities (75.0% to 94.1%) while Stage One NYC led New York (89.7%) and OrganizDwell led Bayonne (72.2%).

City-market #1 winners across 22 local leaderboards

Independent local and regional operators held #1 outright in 13 of 17 tested Oklahoma and New York locations and tied for #1 in Summit, OK (14 of 17, 82.4%); national chains Terminix and Orkin led 3 outright and tied in 1.

Mentioned in (%) ยท Top 10 of 17

  • New Hyde Park, NY ยท Colony Pest Management, Inc.73.3%
  • Fort Gibson, OK ยท Bowden Termite & Pest Control66.7%
  • Nassau County, NY ยท Terminix53.8%
  • Muskogee, OK ยท Orkin53.3%
  • North Hempstead, NY ยท Parkway Pest Services53.3%
  • Midwest City, OK ยท Pest Brothers Pest Control52.6%
  • Oklahoma City, OK ยท Priority Pest & Mosquito Solutions52.6%
  • Old Westbury, NY ยท Fox Pest Control46.2%
  • Bethany, OK ยท Priority Pest & Mosquito Solutions42.1%
  • Oklahoma ยท Romex Pest Control42.1%
  • 0%20%40%60%80%
Explore the data (17 rows)
New Hyde Park, NYColony Pest Management, Inc.73.315
Fort Gibson, OKBowden Termite & Pest Control66.715
Nassau County, NYTerminix53.813
Muskogee, OKOrkin53.315
North Hempstead, NYParkway Pest Services53.315
Midwest City, OKPest Brothers Pest Control52.619
Oklahoma City, OKPriority Pest & Mosquito Solutions52.619
Old Westbury, NYFox Pest Control46.213
Bethany, OKPriority Pest & Mosquito Solutions42.119
OklahomaRomex Pest Control42.119
Crekola, OKWest Termite, Pest & Lawn36.411
Roslyn Harbor, NYTerminix35.714
Wybark, OKBowden Termite & Pest Control35.714
Del City, OKPriority Pest & Mosquito Solutions33.318
Hempstead, NYJoroba Pest Corp33.315
The Village, OKAxcel Pest Control31.316
Summit, OKOrkin / West Termite, Pest & Lawn (tie)28.614
Daily city-market leaderboards on November 19, 2026. Switch between Pest Control Services (17 cities) and Home Staging Furniture Rental Services (5 cities).

Takeaway

Local AI visibility is hyper-municipal: two towns ten miles apart routinely elect different #1 providers.

Single-city and regional brands capture 59.5% of resolved local listings

Across all 12,876 brand-resolved local listings, chains present in 20 or more cities held just 2.6% of total listing volume (334 listings across 4 brands). Meanwhile, single-city businesses captured 26.5% (3,417 listings across 1,669 brands) and 2-to-4 city regional operators captured 33.0% (4,253 listings across 697 brands). Together, single-city and regional operators claimed 59.5% of all resolved local placements.

Multi-metro brands spanning 5 to 19 cities captured the single largest slice at 37.8% (4,872 listings across 182 brands), driven heavily by ChatGPT Search (2,680 ChatGPT listings vs 2,225 on Google). Wider geographic footprints did earn slightly higher average list positions, moving from a mean rank of 2.68 for single-city brands to 2.25 for 20+ city chains.

Local listing share and average rank by brand city footprint

Share (%) ยท 4 results

  • Multi-metro (5 to 19 cities)37.8%
  • Regional (2 to 4 cities)33%
  • Single-city (1 city)26.5%
  • National (20+ cities)2.6%
  • 0%10%20%30%40%
Explore the data (4 rows)
Multi-metro (5 to 19 cities)1824,87237.82,6802,2252.38
Regional (2 to 4 cities)6974,253331,8172,4822.49
Single-city (1 city)1,6693,41726.51,3912,0382.68
National (20+ cities)43342.61471942.25
12,876 resolved local listings grouped by how many distinct cities each brand appeared in (August 1 through November 19, 2026).

Takeaway

National scale gives chains a modest rank edge (2.25 vs 2.68), but single-city and regional operators hold nearly 60% of local placements.

Dominant metro winners often appear on only one AI engine

The 17.2% cross-engine #1 agreement rate isn't just about tie-breakers between two strong runners-up. Major multi-city winners routinely vanish completely from the rival engine. Across the local listing corpus, The Cheesecake Baker appeared 185 times across 12 cities on ChatGPT Search and earned 112 #1 placements, with zero appearances on Google AI Mode.

The mirror opposite happens just as starkly: Deluxe Fit Food appeared 165 times across 13 cities on Google AI Mode and ranked #1 in 149 of them, yet recorded zero appearances on ChatGPT Search. Nutriente Pastry Studio (121 ChatGPT, 0 Google across 13 cities) and Einstein Bros. Bagels (119 ChatGPT, 0 Google across 12 cities) show the same blind spot.

Top single-engine local exclusives across cities

ChatGPT listings ยท 9 results

  • The Cheesecake Baker185
  • Nutriente Pastry Studio121
  • Einstein Bros. Bagels119
  • Great Buns Bakery67
  • Jamie's Bakery54
  • Julia's Oven53
  • Sugar Bee's Bakery44
  • Premium Hardwoods Inc.40
  • Deluxe Fit Food0
  • 050100150200
Explore the data (9 rows)
The Cheesecake Baker121850112185
Deluxe Fit Food130165149165
Nutriente Pastry Studio13121066121
Einstein Bros. Bagels12119049119
Great Buns Bakery13670467
Jamie's Bakery12540654
Julia's Oven12530353
Sugar Bee's Bakery10440444
Premium Hardwoods Inc.54001840
Brands with 40+ local listings across 5 to 13 cities appearing on one engine only (August 1 through November 19, 2026).

Takeaway

Checking local visibility on one engine leaves huge blind spots: a category leader on Google can be completely absent on ChatGPT, and vice versa.

What to do with these numbers

Track each service city and suburb separately on both ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode. Because the two engines pick the same #1 business just 17.2% of the time and suburban prompts in places like Sunrise Manor and Summerlin South drift into central metros up to 12.4% of the time, blended metro averages hide real gaps at the town level.

Structure every location page with complete street addresses and explicit neighborhood and service-area boundaries. ChatGPT Search includes street addresses on 97.5% of local recommendations, while Google AI Mode attaches neighborhoods on 46.1% of place cards. Clear local entities on dedicated city pages help both retrieval paths stay anchored to the exact market you serve.

Local AI visibility checklist by finding

1. Cross-engine split17.2% #1 agreement (88 of 511 matched prompts)Monitor both ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode per city instead of assuming one engine tracks the other
2. Engine metadata gapChatGPT 97.5% street address; Google 46.1% neighborhoodPublish exact street addresses, suite numbers, and explicit neighborhood names on every location page
3. Suburb drift11.06% placeless drift on ChatGPT; 9.4% to 12.4% in Las Vegas suburbsCreate dedicated city and suburb landing pages rather than relying on one metro-wide homepage
4. Hyper-local winners14 of 17 Pest Control cities led or tied by local operatorsBenchmark against local town specialists in each suburb, not only national franchises
Action plan backed by August 1 through November 19, 2026 local listing, drift, and city leaderboard findings.

Takeaway

Local AI visibility requires city-by-city monitoring on both engines plus explicit street-address and neighborhood signals on every location page.
  • Research local markets and sources in Parse
  • Query local market rankings directly via Parse MCP

Study scope and counting rules

The local listing corpus covers 17,121 parsed business listings across 5,666 local answers on ChatGPT Search (8,199 numbered-block listings across 2,415 answers) and Google AI Mode (8,922 place-card listings across 3,251 answers) from August 1 through November 19, 2026. Of those listings, 12,876 resolved to canonical brand entities across 2,552 brands for city-footprint tier analysis.

Geographic place-drift checks cover 12,380 local answers (5,327 explicitly placed and 1,212 placeless local prompts on ChatGPT Search; 5,601 explicitly placed and 240 placeless local prompts on Google AI Mode). An answer counts as drifted when Parse's place classifier flags recommended businesses located outside the requested or home city. Matched cross-engine agreement evaluates 2,549 matched local prompts answered by both engines, narrowing to 623 pairs where both returned local listings and 511 pairs where both resolved a #1 brand.

City-market leaderboards reflect a single daily snapshot on November 19, 2026 across 22 city markets (17 Pest Control Services markets in Oklahoma and New York, and 5 Home Staging Furniture Rental Services markets in New York and New Jersey). Single-engine exclusives include resolved local brands with at least 40 total listings appearing exclusively on ChatGPT Search or exclusively on Google AI Mode during the study window.

How we measured

We analyzed 17,121 parsed local business listings across 5,666 local answers (8,199 ChatGPT Search listings across 2,415 answers; 8,922 Google AI Mode listings across 3,251 answers) and 12,380 geographic place-drift evaluations from August 1 through November 19, 2026, alongside 2,549 matched local questions and 22 daily city-market leaderboards on November 19, 2026.

Matched prompts where ChatGPT and Google named the same #1 local business
17.2%

88 of 511 matched prompts with a resolved #1 on both engines

Geographic drift when ChatGPT prompts omit the city
11.06%

134 of 1,212 placeless prompts vs 4.47% (238 of 5,327) when city is named

Pest Control city markets led or tied by independent local operators
82.4%

14 of 17 Oklahoma and New York locations (13 outright, 1 tie; Nov 19, 2026)

Resolved local listings held by 1-city and 2-to-4-city brands
59.5%

26.5% single-city and 33.0% regional across 12,876 listings

Get the data

Full study dataset (CSV)Engine listing formats, matched agreement, city drift rates, footprint tiers, and single-engine local winners (August 1 through November 19, 2026).

More like this

Does AI localize brand recommendations by country?
Naming a country outside the US often brought a local brand first. Naming the US barely changed the answer.
The single-engine trap: 74% of brands win on only one AI engine
73.8% of recommended brands appeared on only ChatGPT or only Google AI Overviews across 16,206 matched buyer questions.
Do ChatGPT and Google recommend the same top brand?
ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode chose the same first recommendation in about a third of matched answers.
ChatGPT vs Google: same winner, different shortlist
ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews picked the same #1 brand in 93% of categories, but their wider shortlists barely overlapped.
Tables vs lists vs prose: how AI answer formatting doubles the brands named
Across 424,604 buyer answers, ChatGPT used tables in 76.5% vs 16.1% on Google AI Mode, expanding shortlists while shifting picks into comparisons.
For agents: this page as Markdown, https://parse.gl/research/local-ai-search-city-recommendations-and-drift.md. JSON, MCP ยท free for the last 90 days, checks from $0.01
Open in ChatGPT (opens in a new tab) Open in Claude (opens in a new tab)

This page

As Markdown: https://parse.gl/research/local-ai-search-city-recommendations-and-drift.md
As CSV: https://parse.gl/research/local-ai-search-city-recommendations-and-drift/dataset.csv
Reuse: Figures and tables on this page are free to republish with attribution: a link to https://parse.gl/research/local-ai-search-city-recommendations-and-drift beside them. A standard followed link (dofollow) is preferred.

Read and search

Any brand's shares and rivals, with 95% ranges: GET https://agent.parse.gl/v1/tools/check_brand?subject=%3Cbrand-domain%3E
A brand's shares by topic, with 95% ranges: GET https://agent.parse.gl/v1/tools/query_metrics?args=%7B%22measures%22%3A%5B%22share_recommended%22%2C%22share_named%22%5D%2C%22subject%22%3A%22%3Cbrd_id%3E%22%2C%22by%22%3A%5B%22topic%22%5D%7D
Search the index: GET https://parse.gl/api/public/search?q=<words>

Connect

Connect an assistant: https://agent.parse.gl/mcp

An agent can save work before signup: POST https://agent.parse.gl/v1/workspaces

What it costs

No account: Public figures and up to 5 examples per list, about 120 brands a day per address.
Free account: $5 in credit, your brand's first check (20 buyer questions) and a free weekly check.
After your first top-up: Exports and deeper search results. The first top-up starts at $5.
Live checks: $0.01 per question per engine ($0.05 on Gemini and Claude).
Full public answers and pages: 25 free per day, then $0.005 each.
Public answers older than 90 days: $0.001 each the first time your workspace counts or lists one, then yours.

Prices: https://parse.gl/pricing.md

Map of the site: https://parse.gl/llms.txt

See which cities and AI engines pick your local brand

Start free in your browser.
Parse

Index

  • Brands
  • Markets
  • Topics
  • How we measure

For agents

  • Docs
  • Connect
  • Workflows
  • llms.txt

Parse

  • Use cases
  • Pricing
  • Research
  • Blog
  • Compare

Company

  • About
  • Contact
  • Corrections

ยฉ 2026 Parse, Inc. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service