Parse
IndexPricing
Sign inCheck your brand
  1. Research
Research
Do ChatGPT and Google rank brands in the same order?

Do ChatGPT and Google rank brands in the same order?

Published Aug 6, 2026Updated Oct 12, 2026

On this page
  • The finding
  • How we measured
  • Sources
  • More like this
  • The finding
  • How we measured
  • Sources
  • More like this

Dimitry ApollonskyFounder, Parse

DataWhat reviewed means

Two engines can recommend the same brands but present a different order. We wanted to measure that disagreement without confusing it with a change in which brands make the list.

We matched pairs of brands appearing in answers to the same prompts on ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode from May 24 to July 16, 2026. For each matched pair, we checked whether the engines placed the brands in the same relative order.

When ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode ranked the same two brands, they reversed the order in 29.4% of matched comparisons.

The engines reversed nearly three in ten shared brand pairs

A comparison counts only when both engines directly ranked the same two brands in answers to the same prompt in the same run. ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode put the same two brands in opposite order in 54,462 of 185,036 matched comparisons, or 29.4%. They kept the same order in 130,574 comparisons, or 70.6%.

One engine's ordered shortlist cannot stand in for the other engine's order. Compare the same prompt on both engines before treating a position as a shared market rank. BrightEdge reported query-level brand recommendation disagreement across three AI platforms. This study narrows the measurement to the relative order of brand pairs already shared by two engines.

Takeaway

Treat each engine's ordered shortlist as a separate measurement.

More than half of comparable answer pairs contained a reversal

At least one shared brand pair reversed in 27,309 of 50,620 comparable answer pairs, or 53.9%. A pair contained a median of three brand-pair comparisons. The remaining 23,311 answer pairs kept the same relative order for every shared pair.

The pair-by-pair rate adds up when an answer contains several shared brands. Audit the whole shortlist rather than relying on one cross-engine average. SparkToro and Gumshoe found that repeated runs rarely reproduced an entire ordered list. This result measures something different: two engines inside the same matched run.

contained at least one reversal
53.9%

27,309 of 50,620 answer pairs

answer pairs contained a reversal
27,309
answer pairs were comparable
50,620
median comparisons per answer pair
3

Takeaway

Review the full shared shortlist because one answer pair can contain several order changes.

The same top brand still left the rest of the order unsettled

When both engines chose the same top brand, 11,438 of 83,764 shared brand-pair comparisons reversed, or 13.7%. At least one reversal appeared in 6,469 of 21,476 same-top-brand answer pairs, or 30.1%. When the top brands differed, 38,683 of 89,083 comparisons reversed, or 43.4%.

First-place agreement is a useful result, but it does not prove that the rest of the shared shortlist has the same order. Measure the winner and the comparisons further down the list separately.

Brand-pair reversal rate by top-brand agreement

  • Same top brand13.7%11,438 of 83,764
  • Different top brand43.4%38,683 of 89,083
  • 0%20%40%60%
Shared brand-pair comparisons in matched answers.

Reversals were almost as common inside both top threes

When both brands appeared in both engines' top three, 9,579 of 33,982 comparisons reversed, or 28.2%. The rate was 17,808 of 60,416, or 29.5%, inside both top fives and 27,075 of 90,638, or 29.9%, when at least one brand ranked sixth or lower.

The headline is not just a side effect of comparisons deep in the list. Teams should compare the order of leading brands as well as the first recommendation.

Brand-pair reversal rate by rank depth

  • Both brands in both top threes28.2%9,579 of 33,982
  • Both brands in both top fives29.5%17,808 of 60,416
  • At least one rank is sixth or lower29.9%27,075 of 90,638
  • 0%10%20%30%
Each comparison appears in only one group.

Longer shared lists made at least one reversal much more likely

At least one reversal appeared in 7,258 of 22,332 answer pairs with two shared ranked brands, or 32.5%. The rate was 9,042 of 15,086, or 59.9%, with three; 9,207 of 11,296, or 81.5%, with four or five; and 1,802 of 1,906, or 94.5%, with six or more.

Any-reversal rates rise automatically with more possible comparisons. Compare answer pairs with similar shared-list sizes before treating one category or brand as unusually unstable.

Answer pairs with at least one reversal

  • 2 shared ranked brands32.5%7,258 of 22,332
  • 3 shared ranked brands59.9%9,042 of 15,086
  • 4 to 5 shared ranked brands81.5%9,207 of 11,296
  • 6 or more shared ranked brands94.5%1,802 of 1,906
  • 0%50%100%
Grouped by the number of brands ranked by both engines.

Takeaway

Compare any-reversal rates only after controlling for shared-list size.

Real estate and professional services had the highest displayed rates

Real Estate reversed 546 of 1,656 comparisons, or 33.0%, and Professional Services reversed 1,294 of 3,955, or 32.7%. Education had the lowest displayed rate at 563 of 2,190, or 25.7%. Every displayed industry contains at least 1,000 comparisons.

Industry changes the comparison baseline, but the observed rates do not show that industry caused an engine to reverse a brand pair. Use the industry breakdown to prioritize review, not to infer a ranking rule.

Selected industry brand-pair reversal rates

  • Real Estate33.0%546 of 1,656
  • Professional Services32.7%1,294 of 3,955
  • Travel and Tourism32.3%405 of 1,252
  • Health Care32.3%707 of 2,191
  • Media and Entertainment27.9%813 of 2,919
  • Content and Publishing27.2%337 of 1,237
  • Gaming26.8%482 of 1,798
  • Education25.7%563 of 2,190
  • 0%10%20%30%40%
Each displayed industry has at least 1,000 comparisons.

Ahrefs and Semrush reversed in about half of their comparisons

Ahrefs and Semrush reversed in 188 of 377 matched comparisons, or 49.9%. Asana and ClickUp had the most reversals among displayed pairs with 279 of 742, or 37.6%. Displayed names were merged to one standard form before publication.

Named pairs identify where to inspect the prompt and answer language. They do not show which engine's order was correct or whether either order affected buyer behavior.

Selected brand pairs with repeated order reversals

Reversal rate · 10 results

  • Ahrefs and Semrush49.9%
  • monday.com and ClickUp43.4%
  • Asana and monday.com40.4%
  • Asana and ClickUp37.6%
  • New Relic and Grafana33.8%
  • Dynatrace and New Relic32.6%
  • Atlassian and Linear31.8%
  • ClickUp and Atlassian31.6%
  • Datadog and Grafana28.2%
  • Dynatrace and Datadog19.2%
  • 0%20%40%60%
Explore the data (10 rows)
Asana and ClickUp27974237.6%99
Datadog and Grafana27095828.2%86
ClickUp and Atlassian25680931.6%90
Asana and monday.com20851540.4%86
monday.com and ClickUp20747743.4%82
Atlassian and Linear19260331.8%53
Ahrefs and Semrush18837749.9%77
Dynatrace and Datadog18395419.2%80
New Relic and Grafana17250933.8%65
Dynatrace and New Relic17152532.6%58

The study compares order only when both engines ranked the same pair

The window produced 187,150 matched answer pairs. Exactly 50,620 contained at least two comparable shared ranked brands, while 136,530 did not. The final set contained no ties, no duplicate comparisons, no blank brand names, and no ranks below one.

The headline was 29.4% from June 1 through July 16, 31.3% with the first qualifying run per prompt, and 29.2% without merging brands into their parent brands. The study does not measure brands that one engine omitted, factual quality, recommendation accuracy, user demand, or causation. It measures relative order only where a direct comparison exists.

matched answer pairs
187,150
answer pairs were comparable
50,620
pairs lacked two comparable shared brands
136,530
tied brand-pair orders
0

What marketers should do

The engines reversed 29.4% of comparable shared brand pairs, and 53.9% of comparable answer pairs contained at least one reversal. Even same-top-brand answer pairs contained a reversal 30.1% of the time.

Track inclusion, first recommendation, and pair-by-pair order as separate measures. Run the same priority prompts on both engines. Review the underlying answer before averaging rank across engines or treating one screenshot as a market position. Rerun this method over the same window length next quarter before treating a change as real movement.

Takeaway

Measure inclusion, first recommendation, and pair-by-pair order separately on both engines.
  • Why one AI visibility score is misleading

How we measured

We analyzed 185,036 comparisons of the same two brands across 101,240 AI answers to 10,929 organic prompts and 14,607 brands on ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode from May 24 through July 16, 2026.

of comparable answer pairs contained at least one reversal
53.9%

27,309 of 50,620

brands appeared in the observed corpus
14,607

43,893 unique brand pairs

organic prompts were compared across both engines
10,929

101,240 AI answers

Get the data

Dataset CSVThe metrics behind every figure in this report.

Sources

  1. BrightEdge: ChatGPT vs Google brand recommendation disagreement (opens in a new tab) · accessed August 6, 2026
  2. SparkToro: AI recommendation consistency (opens in a new tab) · accessed August 6, 2026
  3. Ahrefs: Brand visibility correlations across AI products (opens in a new tab) · accessed August 6, 2026

More like this

Do ChatGPT and Google pick the same brand in head-to-head comparisons?
ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode picked the same winner in most matched head-to-head comparisons.
Do ChatGPT and Google recommend the same top brand?
ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode chose the same first recommendation in about a third of matched answers.
ChatGPT vs Google: same winner, different shortlist
ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews usually shared the leading brand across buyer categories, but their wider shortlists differed.
Does AI recommend the same brand when you ask again?
Asking the same engine the same question again kept the first recommendation in only about six in ten comparisons.
How often does a mentioned brand rank first?
Only about one in eight brands mentioned in an AI answer was its actual pick.
Do ChatGPT and Google criticize the same brands?
When one engine criticized a brand both ranked, the other usually did not share that criticism.

See how your brand ranks across AI engines.

Parse

Index

  • Brands
  • Markets
  • Topics
  • How we measure

For agents

  • Docs
  • Connect
  • Workflows
  • llms.txt

Parse

  • Pricing
  • Research
  • Blog
  • Compare

Company

  • About
  • Contact
  • Corrections

© 2026 Parse, Inc. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service