OXO has a narrow lead over Tovolo among recommendations for an ice cube tray. The supplied material does not identify a question or situation where another brand is recommended most.
Rigid stainless-steel frame means it doesn't flop around when full
Lid helps prevent freezer odors and allows stacking
Dishwasher safe and BPA/PFAS-free
Currently about $16 from W&P
Food Network and Liquor.com both independently rated this W&P model among their top choices, with Liquor.com naming it best overall after hands-on testing.
Best value:Tovolo Perfect Cube — makes 15 cubes per tray, releases easily, and is around $15 for a two-pack. Good Housekeeping named it its best overall tray.
Best for preventing spills/odors:OXO Good Grips — excellent if your freezer is crowded or you frequently move trays around.
Best for whiskey/Old Fashioneds:Tovolo King Cube — its 2-inch cubes melt more slowly, reducing dilution.
Best premium large cube:W&P Extra Large — makes four 2¼-inch cubes with a lid and steel frame.
My verdict: For normal water, iced coffee, cocktails, and general kitchen use, buy the W&P Peak Everyday. If you want the best bang for your money, I'd get the Tovolo Perfect Cube 2-pack instead.
The "best" ice cube tray depends entirely on what kind of ice you want and how much space you have . According to testing from expert publications like The New York Times Wirecutter and Food & Wine , top options break down by category:
Best Silicone Tray (Everyday Cubes):Glacio Ice Cube Tray
Makes 21 medium-sized square cubes per tray. It features beveled compartments and comes with a plastic lid, making it easy to pop out cubes without twisting a stiff plastic frame or spilling water on the way to the freezer.[](https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/the-best-ice-cube-tray/)
Best Traditional Plastic Tray:OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray
Makes 14 classic half-moon cubes and features a clever sliding stackable lid that keeps freezer odors out and lets you stack other items on top of it.[](https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/the-best-ice-cube-tray/)
Best Budget / Basic Tray:Rubbermaid Quick Release Ice Cube Tray
An affordable, flexible polypropylene and thermoplastic elastomer tray with gripping handles that twist effortlessly to release standard 1-ounce cubes.[](https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/the-best-ice-cube-tray/)
I looked at current product listings and expert-tested reviews to find ice cube trays worth buying. My advice: get a tray with a lid and an easy-release design so your ice stays fresh, the tray stacks neatly, and you don't have to wrestle with frozen cubes.
The strongest options range from inexpensive everyday trays to premium silicone and stainless steel models. Food Network's 2026 testing named DOQAUS its best overall pick, while other reviewers highlighted OXO and W&P for practical everyday use.
Ecozoi Ice Maker Tray for Freezer, Stainless Steel Ice Cubes…
4.9/5 (327 reviews)
$45.45
A reusable 304 stainless steel option with an easy-release handle. Worth considering if you want to avoid silicone and ordinary plastic; it costs considerably more than basic trays.
Prices and availability can change. Ratings reflect the available retailer listings and are not directly comparable across products with different numbers of reviews.
Which one should you buy?
For most people: OXO two-pack with lids — practical and versatile.
For the lowest price: Rubbermaid Quick Release.
For easy removal and nicer-looking cubes: Tovolo silicone set.
For avoiding plastic and silicone: Ecozoi stainless steel.
For cocktails and whiskey: OXO large-cube tray.
One consideration: Consumer Reports found that some silicone trays absorbed odors more readily than plastic or stainless steel trays, so proper washing and a protective lid are useful.
What's most important to you? I can narrow this to the best option for your needs.
The top-rated and expert-recommended options are categorized by what they do best:
Best Overall Standard Trays
Widely praised by culinary publications (like The Spruce Eats and Food & Wine ). It features an internal steel-reinforced rim that keeps the silicone sturdy so it doesn't flop and spill when walking to the freezer, plus a fitted lid that allows stacking and prevents freezer odors.
A massive favorite on Amazon and top-rated for everyday use. Comes in a 2-pack, made of flexible silicone with beveled compartments that make popping individual cubes out effortless.[](]()]()
Highly rated for people with crowded or small freezers. It features a silicone lid that seals tightly so water doesn't slop out on the way to the freezer, and the flat, stackable design lets you pile things right on top of it.[](https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/the-best-ice-cube-tray/)
Best for Large / Specialty Ice (Cocktails & Whiskey)
The gold standard for oversized 2-inch square cubes. They melt remarkably slow, keeping spirit-forward drinks cold without over-diluting them.
If you prefer a classic, semi-flexible plastic/polypropylene tray rather than silicone, this budget-friendly 2-pack features gripping handles and a twist-and-pop release that costs just a few dollars.[](https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/the-best-ice-cube-tray/)
If you want to narrow this down, let me know:
What type of ice you prefer (standard, large cubes, spheres, or small nugget ice)
Whether you need a lid to stack things in your freezer
I can give you a specific recommendation and current pricing!
