If you're a gig worker in Indiana, the best balance is generally a Silver plan, with Anthem looking like the strongest starting point for moderate expected medical use.
For 2026, Indiana has five Marketplace insurers: Anthem, CareSource, Cigna, Coordinated Care, and UnitedHealthcare.
My pick: Anthem Silver
A 2026 comparison of Indiana Marketplace plans found that Anthem's Silver HMO averaged about $482/month, with a $2,861 deductible and $5,224 average out-of-pocket maximum for a 40-year-old. CareSource averaged $603/month/$3,040 deductible, while Ambetter averaged $548/month/$3,268 deductible.
So, for someone expecting regular but not extremely heavy usage—say several doctor visits, prescriptions, labs, or an occasional urgent-care visit—I'd favor:
Anthem → Silver → choose the specific Silver plan with the best copays/OOP maximum in your county.
Why Silver rather than Bronze? Bronze typically gives you the lowest premium but substantially higher cost-sharing; Silver is designed as the middle ground. And if your income qualifies you for cost-sharing reductions (CSRs), Silver becomes particularly attractive because those extra savings can lower deductibles, copays, and coinsurance.
When I'd choose something else
- Low medical use / very healthy: Bronze may win if the premium savings are substantial and you have enough cash to handle a large deductible.
- Frequent medical use or expensive prescriptions: Price out Gold carefully. Indiana's unusual cost-sharing structure can make Gold surprisingly competitive.
- Income eligible for CSRs: Silver is usually the clear choice. Don't buy Bronze or Gold without first comparing the subsidized Silver plans.
- Very high expected expenses: Compare the annual premium plus the out-of-pocket maximum—not merely the deductible.
The key calculation is:
Expected annual cost ≈ 12 × monthly premium + expected medical cost-sharing.
HealthCare.gov specifically recommends comparing estimated total yearly costs, including premiums, deductible, copays/coinsurance, and the out-of-pocket maximum.
If you give me your ZIP code, age, estimated 2026 income, and expected usage (e.g., “healthy except 2 prescriptions and 4 doctor visits”), I can compare the actual Indiana plans and tell you which insurer + specific metal tier is likely cheapest for your situation.