Assuming you mean New Jersey, the 2026 small-group market is primarily AmeriHealth, Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey, and Oxford. The state reports average 2026 small-employer rate changes of 6.7% for AmeriHealth, 17.7% for Horizon, and 15.0% for Oxford.
That makes AmeriHealth worth putting at the top of your cost/value comparison, but I wouldn't call any carrier objectively “best” without seeing your group's actual quotes. Premiums, employee ages, ZIP codes, preferred doctors/hospitals, deductible, copays, and network design can change the result substantially.
| Carrier | 2026 avg. small-group rate change | What to examine |
|---|
| AmeriHealth | 6.7% | Premium, network, deductible/copays |
| Oxford | 15.0% | Network and plan design versus premium |
| Horizon BCBSNJ | 17.7% | Broad provider access versus premium |
The 6.7% figure is a statewide average rate action, not a quote for your business, so it shouldn't be interpreted as saying AmeriHealth will necessarily be cheapest for your employees.
New Jersey's SHOP program is available to businesses with 1–50 employees, and eligible employers may qualify for a small-business health-care tax credit of up to 50% of the employer contribution.
If you give me (1) your New Jersey ZIP code, (2) number of employees, (3) approximate ages, and (4) how much of the premium you want the business to pay, I can compare the current small-group options and show the estimated employer and employee costs side-by-side, rather than relying on statewide averages.