What is the best smart scale?

Best smart scale overall: Withings Body Smart

• Withings Body Smart - $129.95 (Nordstrom)

For most people, I’d buy the Withings Body Smart. Current 2026 testing from Tom’s Guide ranks it best overall, while other recent comparisons also favor it over the Garmin Index S2 for general health tracking.

Why I like it:

• Tracks weight, body fat, muscle mass, water, bone mass, BMI, visceral fat and more.
• Measures heart rate.
• Wi-Fi + Bluetooth means weigh-ins can sync automatically.
• Supports multiple users plus athlete, pregnancy, baby and eyes-closed modes.
• Excellent Withings app for seeing long-term trends.
• Around $130 currently, which makes it a strong value.

My shortlist

• Withings Body Smart - $129.95 (Nordstrom)

• Withings Body Comp - $229.95 (Nordstrom)

• Garmin Index S2 - $199.99 (Target)

• Wyze Scale X - $38.98 (Wyze)

• RENPHO MorphoScan Smart Body Scale - $125.99 (RENPHO US)

• Best overall: Withings Body Smart — the one I'd recommend to most people.

• Best premium: Withings Body Comp — more advanced health measurements, but considerably more expensive.

• Best for Garmin users: Garmin Index S2 — particularly worthwhile if you already use Garmin Connect.

• Best budget: Wyze Scale X — inexpensive while still providing extensive body-composition tracking.

• Best for detailed body composition: RENPHO MorphoScan — uses an 8-electrode design and provides 50+ metrics.

One important caveat: don't treat the body-fat/muscle numbers as exact. Consumer scales use bioelectrical impedance (BIA), and hydration, meals, exercise and other factors can move the estimates around. They're most useful for tracking trends under consistent conditions, not as a substitute for a clinical measurement.

If you tell me your budget (e.g. under $50, $100, $200) and whether you use iPhone/Apple Health, Android, or Garmin, I can narrow it down to the single best choice for you.

The Wyze Scale X Go to product viewer dialog for this item. stands out as the best smart scale overall for its excellent mix of affordability, app design, and versatile tracking modes. If you are looking for top-tier health metrics, the Withings Body Smart Scale Go to product viewer dialog for this item. is the premium expert choice, while the RENPHO Elis 1 Go to product viewer dialog for this item. remains the top pick for tight budgets.

The top smart scales on the market are grouped below by their best use cases:

Best Overall & Budget-Friendly Picks

• Standout Value : Lauded by Wirecutter for its accurate readings, encrypted data privacy, and a clean, informative app.

• Versatile Modes : Features specialized, safe-tracking modes for babies, pets, pregnancy, and luggage.

• Ultra-Affordable : The definitive budget favorite that reliably monitors 13 essential metrics including weight, BMI, and muscle mass.

• App Integration : Seamlessly syncs via Bluetooth with popular fitness platforms like Apple Health, Google Fit, and Fitbit.[1]

Best Premium & Fitness Ecosystem Scales

• Advanced Health Metrics : Tracks visceral fat index, basal metabolic rate (BMR), and standing heart rate trends over time.

• Robust Connectivity : Automatically syncs over both Wi-Fi and Bluetooth to a highly regarded, easy-to-read app ecosystem.[1]

• Athlete-Focused : Specifically designed for deep integration into the Garmin Connect platform to map metrics alongside workout data.

• Premium Display : Features a sharp, high-resolution color screen that displays immediate trend graphs directly on the platform.[1]

To help you find the absolute perfect match, what fitness apps or smartwatches do you currently use (like Apple Health, Garmin, or Fitbit)? Also, are you looking for a model that multiple family members can share?

The Wyze Scale X Go to product viewer dialog for this item. stands out as the best smart scale overall for its excellent mix of affordability, app design, and versatile tracking modes. If you are looking for top-tier health metrics, the Withings Body Smart Scale Go to product viewer dialog for this item. is the premium expert choice, while the RENPHO Elis 1 Go to product viewer dialog for this item. remains the top pick for tight budgets.

The top smart scales on the market are grouped below by their best use cases:

Best Overall & Budget-Friendly Picks

• Standout Value : Lauded by Wirecutter for its accurate readings, encrypted data privacy, and a clean, informative app.

• Versatile Modes : Features specialized, safe-tracking modes for babies, pets, pregnancy, and luggage.

• Ultra-Affordable : The definitive budget favorite that reliably monitors 13 essential metrics including weight, BMI, and muscle mass.

• App Integration : Seamlessly syncs via Bluetooth with popular fitness platforms like Apple Health, Google Fit, and Fitbit.[1]

Best Premium & Fitness Ecosystem Scales

• Advanced Health Metrics : Tracks visceral fat index, basal metabolic rate (BMR), and standing heart rate trends over time.

• Robust Connectivity : Automatically syncs over both Wi-Fi and Bluetooth to a highly regarded, easy-to-read app ecosystem.[1]

• Athlete-Focused : Specifically designed for deep integration into the Garmin Connect platform to map metrics alongside workout data.

• Premium Display : Features a sharp, high-resolution color screen that displays immediate trend graphs directly on the platform.[1]

To help you find the absolute perfect match, what fitness apps or smartwatches do you currently use (like Apple Health, Garmin, or Fitbit)? Also, are you looking for a model that multiple family members can share?

The best smart scale for most people is the Withings Body Comp Smart Scale. It has the strongest combination of measurement features, app quality, long-term health tracking, and ease of use.

Here are the top picks depending on what you want:

Best overall: Withings Body Comp Smart Scale

Best for: Most households, health tracking, Apple Health users Why it stands out:

• Excellent app and trend tracking
• Tracks weight, body composition, visceral fat estimates, heart-related metrics, and more
• Wi-Fi syncing means you don’t need your phone nearby
• Supports multiple users well

Downside: More expensive than basic smart scales, and some advanced features may require a subscription.

Best for athletes: Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale

Best for: Garmin watch owners, runners, cyclists, serious fitness tracking

• Syncs directly with Garmin Connect
• Tracks weight trends, body fat percentage, BMI, and muscle mass
• Fits naturally into the Garmin ecosystem

Downside: Less useful if you don’t already use Garmin products.

Best budget pick: RENPHO Smart Body Fat Scale

Best for: Getting smart-scale features cheaply

• Usually far less expensive than premium models
• Tracks basics like weight, BMI, body fat, and muscle estimates
• Good choice if you mainly want trends rather than advanced health insights

Downside: App experience and measurement consistency are not as polished as Withings.

Best value premium option: Withings Body Smart Advanced Body Composition Smart Wi-Fi Scale

Best for: People who want a high-quality scale without paying for the flagship model

• Strong app ecosystem
• Good balance of features and price

My quick recommendation:

• Buy once, keep for years: Withings Body Comp
• Already own a Garmin watch: Garmin Index S2
• Under ~$50: RENPHO
• Want the simplest good experience: Withings Body Smart

One thing to keep in mind: smart scales are most useful for tracking trends over time. Body-fat and muscle readings from home scales are estimates, so the day-to-day changes matter more than any single measurement.

• Buy once, keep for years: Withings Body Comp
• Already own a Garmin watch: Garmin Index S2
• Under ~$50: RENPHO
• Want the simplest good experience: Withings Body Smart

One thing to keep in mind: smart scales are most useful for tracking trends over time. Body-fat and muscle readings from home scales are estimates, so the day-to-day changes matter more than any single measurement.

If you want one smart scale that’s best for most people, I’d pick the Withings Body Smart.

• Withings Body Smart - $129.95 (Best Buy)

My picks

• 🥇 Best overall: Withings Body Smart — Excellent app, Wi-Fi + Bluetooth, weight/body-fat/muscle/water tracking, multiple users, and useful athlete/pregnancy modes. Current testing also rates it highly for overall value.
• 🏆 Best premium: Withings Body Scan — Much more sophisticated, including segmental body composition using hand + foot electrodes. Best if you really want detailed body-composition tracking and don't mind spending ~$500.
• 🏃 Best for Garmin users: Garmin Index S2 — Particularly attractive if you already use Garmin Connect. Otherwise, I think the Withings Body Smart offers more for the money.
• 💰 Best inexpensive option: RENPHO — You can get a capable smart scale for around $40–50, making it a good choice if you primarily want weight trends and basic body-composition estimates.

One important caveat

Don't buy a smart scale because it claims to measure 15–50 different things. Body-fat, muscle, visceral fat, metabolic age, etc. are estimates from BIA, and hydration, food, exercise, and other factors can substantially affect them. They're much more useful for watching trends over time than treating the individual numbers as precise measurements.

My recommendation: Spend ~$100–130 on the Withings Body Smart rather than $400–600 on a premium scale unless you specifically want advanced segmental measurements.

If you tell me your budget (e.g. under $100, $200, or money-no-object) and whether you use Apple Health, Fitbit, Garmin, or Samsung Health, I can narrow it down to the best 2–3 choices.

The top-rated smart scales excel at specific priorities, with the [Withings Body Comp Go to product viewer dialog for this item. ](https://www.withings.com/en-us/products/body-comp-white?variant=57641251176822&srsltid=AfmBOopgfSaG92x1MildC_x2EHazK-a7pffVzK-6g9lgpMpW8BIscAcBADQ) leading for advanced health insights, the Wyze Scale X Go to product viewer dialog for this item. dominating for budget-friendliness, and the Eufy Smart Scale P2 Go to product viewer dialog for this item. offering the best balance of household features and overall value. [1][2]

Best Smart Scales Compared

Add to list

• Best for Longevity & Biomarkers : Tracks vascular age, standing heart rate, visceral fat, and electrodermal activity.
• Standout Specs : High-contrast color display, Wi-Fi/Bluetooth auto-sync, 15-month battery life. [1][2]

Add to list

• Best Budget Option : Wirecutter's top choice offering reliable weight and 13 metrics at a low cost.
• Standout Specs : Baby, pet, and luggage modes; encrypted data transfer.

Add to list

• Best Value Overall : Highly accurate weight readings, 15 distinct health metrics, and unlimited user profiles.
• Standout Specs : In-app 3D virtual body reports, Bluetooth/Wi-Fi tracking, budget-friendly pricing.

Add to list

• Best for In-Depth Body Fat : Utilizes a built-in 8-electrode handlebar to capture upper and lower body composition accurately.
• Standout Specs : Tracks over 50 metrics, free tracking app, built-in digital display handle.[1]

Add to list

• Best for Athletes : Seamlessly hooks into the Garmin Connect ecosystem to overlay weight with workout strain.
• Standout Specs : High-resolution color screen, weather widget, tracks skeletal muscle and hydration. [1][2]

Key Considerations Before Buying

While standard weight metrics are highly reliable across all these models, bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) for body fat and muscle mass can vary between brands. Experts suggest tracking your biometrics as a trend line over time rather than treating the absolute numbers as absolute clinical values.

To narrow down your options, please let me know:

• Do you already use a fitness tracker like an Apple Watch, Garmin , or Fitbit?
• What is your approximate budget?
• Do you need a scale that supports multiple users or a specific mode like pregnancy/baby mode?

If you want one smart scale that’s the best overall for most people, I’d pick the Withings Body Smart.

• Withings Body Smart - $129.95 (Nordstrom)

My picks

• 🏆 Best overall: Withings Body Smart — excellent balance of weight tracking, body-composition measurements, Wi-Fi/Bluetooth connectivity, and a polished app. Current retail listings are around $130. Recent 2026 testing/reviews consistently put Withings among the top choices.

• 🏃 Best for Garmin users: Garmin Index S2 — particularly compelling if you already use a Garmin watch and Garmin Connect. It tracks weight, BMI, body fat, skeletal muscle, bone mass and body water.

• 💰 Best budget: RENPHO Elis 1 — around $25, with 13 body measurements and app tracking. Great if you mainly want inexpensive weight/body-fat trends rather than premium features.

• 📊 Best for lots of body-composition data: RENPHO MorphoScan — 8-electrode technology and 50+ metrics, though I wouldn't pay extra simply because it reports more numbers; body-composition estimates from consumer BIA scales are best treated as trend indicators, not precise measurements.

• Withings Body Smart - $129.95 (Nordstrom)

• Garmin Index S2 - $199.99 (Target)

• RENPHO Elis 1 - $24.99 (RENPHO US)

• RENPHO MorphoScan - $179.99 (RENPHO US)

My recommendation: Buy the Withings Body Smart unless you're already heavily invested in Garmin. It's the sweet spot of accuracy, useful features, app quality, and price.

If you tell me your budget (e.g. under $50, $100, $150, $250) and whether you use iPhone/Apple Health, Fitbit, or Garmin, I can narrow it down to the best 1–2 choices.

The Wyze Scale X Go to product viewer dialog for this item. stands out as the best smart scale overall for most users due to its exceptional accuracy, massive 22-month battery life, and highly affordable price point.

When shopping for a smart scale, your choice largely depends on whether you want a budget-friendly option for simple weight tracking or a premium, multi-electrode system for medical-grade body composition monitoring.

The Best Smart Scales

Add to list

• Best Overall : Highly praised by reviewers from The New York Times Wirecutter for its incredible value, 400-pound weight capacity, and seamless syncing with Apple Health, Google Fit, and Fitbit.
• Standout Features : Exceptional 22-month battery life via AAA batteries and specialized tracking modes for luggage, pets, and babies.

Add to list

• Best Premium Health Station : Features a retractable handle with 4 built-in electrodes to perform advanced, clinical-grade segmental body composition tracking.
• Advanced Metrics : Delivers 6-lead ECG readings, vascular age, standing heart rate, and an EDA score to evaluate sweat gland response.[1][2]

Add to list

• Best Budget Option : An incredibly cost-effective option that measures 13 key body metrics—including BMI, bone mass, and metabolic age—via Bluetooth.
• User Experience : Highly favored across fitness communities on Reddit's MacroFactor Forum for its reliable weight tracking and highly intuitive companion app. [1][2]

Add to list

• Best Mid-Range Wi-Fi Scale : Provides an excellent middle ground, utilizing automatic Wi-Fi data uploads so you don't need your phone nearby during weigh-ins.
• Long-Term Utility : Tracks nerve health, visceral fat, and cardiovascular trends for up to 8 distinct users with automatic profile recognition.[1]

Add to list

• Best for In-Depth Data : Uses an 8-electrode system to capture 31 distinct bio-metrics, displaying live data changes in real time on its crisp 3-inch OLED handle screen.
• Convenience : Operates on a built-in lithium-ion battery that fully recharges in under an hour via a standard USB-C cable.[1]

Community Perspectives on Body Composition Accuracy

While smart scales are excellent tools for charting long-term weight trends, health and fitness communities emphasize that secondary metrics like body fat percentage should be taken with a grain of salt.

“Though unless you're lucky like me, an occasional visual body fat estimate might be more accurate than the number it actually gives you for body fat - so you might not want MF to actually use the body fat data. Though you might find it useful anyway, at...”

“I have a Renpho smart scale, works great with macrofactor. I don't worry to much about all the metrics just the overall weight.”

Smart Scale Feature Comparison

To help narrow down the ideal option, tell me if you are looking to sync the scale with a specific fitness ecosystem (like Apple Health, Garmin, or Fitbit), or if you have a specific budget in mind.[1][2]

The best smart scale for most people is the Withings Body Smart. It offers the best balance of useful metrics, app quality, reliability, and price. It tracks weight trends, body fat, muscle mass, water, BMI, visceral fat estimates, and more, while supporting Wi-Fi syncing so your data updates automatically.

Here are the top picks by use case:

Best overall: Withings Body Smart

Best for: Most households, weight loss, general health tracking Why it stands out:

• Excellent app experience
• Wi-Fi syncing
• Multiple user profiles
• Useful body composition trends
• Good balance of features and cost

Downside: Like all consumer smart scales, body-fat and muscle estimates are best used for tracking trends, not as medical measurements.

Best premium: Withings Body Scan

Best for: People who want the most advanced home health tracking Why it stands out:

• More advanced body composition analysis
• Additional cardiovascular and wellness measurements
• Premium build and ecosystem

Downside: Expensive; it is overkill if you only want weight tracking.

Best for Garmin users: Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale

Best for: Runners, cyclists, and people already using Garmin watches Why it stands out:

• Seamless Garmin Connect integration
• Tracks weight, BMI, body fat, muscle mass, and water percentage

Downside: Outside the Garmin ecosystem, it offers less value than some competitors.

Best budget choice: RENPHO Elis 2X Smart Scale

Best for: Affordable tracking of basic body metrics Why it stands out:

• Low cost
• Tracks many metrics through the app
• Good choice if you mainly want weight trends and basic composition estimates

My quick recommendation:

• Most people: Withings Body Smart
• Apple Health / general wellness: Withings Body Smart or Body Comp
• Garmin watch owners: Garmin Index S2
• Under ~$50: RENPHO
• Fitness enthusiasts who want maximum data: Withings Body Scan

One thing to keep in mind: smart scales are most useful when you weigh yourself under similar conditions and watch long-term trends rather than day-to-day fluctuations.

• Most people: Withings Body Smart
• Apple Health / general wellness: Withings Body Smart or Body Comp
• Garmin watch owners: Garmin Index S2
• Under ~$50: RENPHO
• Fitness enthusiasts who want maximum data: Withings Body Scan

One thing to keep in mind: smart scales are most useful when you weigh yourself under similar conditions and watch long-term trends rather than day-to-day fluctuations.

The "best" smart scale depends on your budget, how deeply you want to track your health metrics, and your ecosystem (Apple Health, Garmin, etc.). Smart scales range from basic budget-friendly weight-and-fat trackers to advanced clinical-grade body analyzers.

The top-rated smart scales on the market are categorized below by what they do best:

1. Best Overall / Most Comprehensive: Withings Body Smart Go to product viewer dialog for this item. / Body Scan Go to product viewer dialog for this item.

Withings is the gold standard for reliable Wi-Fi smart scales with a phenomenal app ecosystem.

• Withings Body Smart: The sweet spot for most people. It tracks weight, body fat/water percentage, muscle/bone mass, visceral fat, and basal metabolic rate, and syncs seamlessly via Wi-Fi or Bluetooth to Apple Health, Google Fit, and others.
• Withings Body Scan (or newer Body Scan 2 Go to product viewer dialog for this item.): For deep health tracking, this ultra-premium option features a retractable handle for segmental body composition (separate readings for arms, legs, and torso), a 6-lead ECG for heart rhythm tracking, and nerve health assessments.
• Check out the ecosystem and options directly on the Withings Scale Comparison.

2. Best for Athletes & Garmin Users: Garmin Index S2 Go to product viewer dialog for this item.

• Why buy it: If you already wear a Garmin watch and use the Garmin Connect App , this is a no-brainer.
• Key Features: It features a high-resolution color screen that displays trend graphs directly on the glass, tracks weight changes throughout the day, measures body fat, muscle mass, water percentage, and bone mass, and includes a handy daily weather forecast widget.
• Explore details or buy via the Garmin Index S2 Product Page. [1]

3. Best Value / Budget Pick: Wyze Scale X Go to product viewer dialog for this item. or Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro Go to product viewer dialog for this item.

• Why buy it: You get 90% of the daily utility (weight, body fat, heart rate, and body composition tracking) for a fraction of the cost of Withings or Garmin.
• Key Features: Eufy’s P2 Pro offers great multi-user tracking, a sleek interface, and an IPX5 water-resistance rating against bathroom splashes. Wyze Scale X is ultra-affordable, handles up to 400 lbs , and accurately tracks a wide array of baseline biometrics.
• Read Wirecutter's testing breakdown on the Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro Review.

Quick Buying Guide: How to Choose

• Choose Wi-Fi over Bluetooth-only: Scales with Wi-Fi automatically sync your data to the cloud the second you step off. Bluetooth-only scales require you to have your phone nearby with the app open every time you weigh yourself.
• Manage expectations on Body Fat %: Consumer smart scales use Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA), which sends a minor electrical current through your feet. While the trends (gaining muscle, losing fat) are helpful, the absolute percentage numbers aren't as precise as a clinical DEXA scan.

If you want to narrow this down, let me know:

• What is your budget range?
• Do you use a specific fitness tracker or smartwatch ecosystem (like Apple, Garmin, or Fitbit)?
• Are you looking for basic weight/composition tracking or advanced heart/health metrics?