How can my business get more leads from our website? Should I hire an agency to help with my SEO and CRO?
Data as of Sep 21, 2026 · Based on 323 AI responses from ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode · See how Parse measures this
Data as of Sep 21, 2026 · Based on 323 AI responses from ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode · See how Parse measures this
Brands AI recommends here
Named in 22% of answers
Named in 16% of answers
Named in 8% of answers
Named in 7% of answers
Source | Citation share |
|---|---|
 DIY SEO vs. Hiring an SEO Company | Learn the Factshttps://uptickmarketing.com/blog/diy-seo-vs-hiring-seo-company/ | 3% |
 10 Ways to Generate More Website Leads in 2026https://formidableforms.com/10-ways-to-generate-more-leads-on-your-site/ | 2% |
 Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO) Agency | Orbit Mediahttps://www.orbitmedia.com/website-optimization/cro/ | 2% |
 5 Reasons to Hire an SEO Agency for Small Business Growthhttps://gasstovecreative.com/5-reasons-to-hire-an-seo-agency-instead-of-doing-it-yourself/ | 2% |
 Should I Hire an SEO Agency or Do SEO Myself?https://avalanchegr.com/blog/diy-seo-vs-seo-agency | 1% |
 Hiring a CRO agency: 12 *Key* Considerations (and Expert Advice)https://www.convertcart.com/blog/choose-conversion-rate-optimization-agency | 1% |
 10 ways to generate more leads from your websitehttps://www.blendb2b.com/blog/generate-website-leads | 1% |
 SEO and CRO: How to Combine Strategies for Better Resultshttps://www.semrush.com/blog/seo-and-cro/ | 1% |
 Hiring In-House vs. an SEO Agency: The Pros and Conshttps://thriveagency.com/news/hiring-in-house-vs-an-seo-agency-the-pros-and-cons-you-should-consider/ | 1% |
 9 Benefits of Hiring an SEO Company - Why Hire an Agency!https://www.titangrowth.com/blog/9-benefits-of-hiring-an-seo-agency/ | 1% |
- **Optimize Conversion Rate (CRO)** Ensure your website turns existing traffic into leads by adding clear, high-contrast call-to-action (CTA) buttons on every page, simplifying contact forms to ask only for essential information, and placing social proof like customer testimonials or case studies near conversion…
To help figure out the best next step, let me know:
No sources cited
Yes—but I wouldn’t hire an agency simply because you want “more leads.” I’d first determine whether your bottleneck is traffic, conversion rate, or lead quality. Otherwise, an agency can spend a lot of money optimizing the wrong problem. A useful way to think about it is: Traffic × conversion rate × lead quality =…
Yes—but I wouldn’t hire an agency simply because you want “more leads.” I’d first determine whether your bottleneck is traffic, conversion rate, or lead quality. Otherwise, an agency can spend a lot of money optimizing the wrong problem.
A useful way to think about it is:
Traffic × conversion rate × lead quality = business opportunity.
At minimum, measure:
No sources cited
Yes—but I wouldn’t start by hiring an agency. **First determine whether your bottleneck is traffic, conversion rate, or lead quality.** An agency can accelerate the work, but it can also become an expensive way to optimize the wrong problem. ## 1. Find the biggest leak first Think of the website as:
Yes—but I wouldn’t start by hiring an agency. First determine whether your bottleneck is traffic, conversion rate, or lead quality. An agency can accelerate the work, but it can also become an expensive way to optimize the wrong problem.
Think of the website as:
Qualified traffic → landing page → inquiry/demo/form → qualified lead → customer
Measure each step. Google Analytics can track form views, starts, submissions, and important actions as “key events,” which lets you see where visitors are dropping out.
For example:
| Situation | Likely priority |
|---|---|
| Very little relevant search traffic | SEO/content |
| Plenty of traffic, few inquiries | CRO/messaging |
| Lots of inquiries, few qualified leads | Targeting/offer/lead qualification |
| Good leads but few customers | Sales process/follow-up |
| Traffic comes from searches you don't actually serve | SEO targeting |
I'd also track qualified leads and revenue, not just form submissions. GA4 supports lead-generation events such as generate_lead, qualify_lead, and close_convert_lead, which can give you a much better picture of the full funnel.
Some relatively high-impact things to examine:
A useful experiment is to take your top 3 pages by organic traffic and ask: “If someone is ready to buy this service, does this page give them a compelling reason and an obvious way to contact us?”
Don't pursue SEO simply to increase traffic.
I'd build a keyword/content strategy around:
Then build authoritative service pages and useful supporting content around those topics.
The goal isn't “10,000 more visitors.” It's more visitors who have a reason to become customers.
I'd consider an agency when at least one of these is true:
I'd be cautious if an agency leads with:
“We'll get you X keywords / X backlinks / X% more traffic.” Instead, ask them to connect their work to qualified leads and revenue.
A good agency should be willing to establish a baseline and explain what it will measure—traffic, landing-page performance, form starts, leads, qualified leads, and eventually customers. GA4 specifically supports using key events to evaluate which acquisition channels lead to meaningful actions.
For many small and midsize businesses, I'd start with a 4–6 week website/SEO audit + implementation sprint, rather than immediately signing a large monthly retainer.
That could include:
Then you have evidence for deciding whether you need ongoing agency help.
If you give me these 8 things, I can help you determine whether your bigger opportunity is SEO, CRO, or both—and whether an agency is likely to make economic sense:
With the URL, I can also do a practical SEO + CRO teardown of the site and identify the highest-priority changes rather than giving you a generic marketing checklist.
For many small and midsize businesses, I'd start with a 4–6 week website/SEO audit + implementation sprint, rather than immediately signing a large monthly retainer.
That could include:
Then you have evidence for deciding whether you need ongoing agency help.
If you give me these 8 things, I can help you determine whether your bigger opportunity is SEO, CRO, or both—and whether an agency is likely to make economic sense:
With the URL, I can also do a practical SEO + CRO teardown of the site and identify the highest-priority changes rather than giving you a generic marketing checklist.
Turning your website into a lead-generation machine comes down to a two-sided coin: **SEO** (bringing the right people to your site) and **CRO** (turning those visitors into leads or buyers once they arrive). ### How to Get More Leads From Your Website (The Fundamentals) Before paying anyone, make sure your foundation…
Turning your website into a lead-generation machine comes down to a two-sided coin: SEO (bringing the right people to your site) and CRO (turning those visitors into leads or buyers once they arrive).
Before paying anyone, make sure your foundation isn't leaking traffic and potential customers:
Deciding whether to outsource depends heavily on your budget, internal bandwidth , and current revenue stage.
I found that hiring an agency only worked once we had a baseline of traffic and a clear offer. Before that, we were just paying them to figure out what we should have already known about our own customers.
An agency gives you a whole team—copywriters, devs, strategists—for less than the cost of one senior full-time hire. But you still have to manage them and know what your goals are.
To help figure out the right next step, tell me:
Yes—but I **wouldn’t hire an SEO/CRO agency just because you want more leads**. First, determine whether your bottleneck is **traffic, conversion, or lead quality**. SEO gets qualified people to the site; CRO turns more of those visitors into inquiries. The two work best together. [HubSpot…
Yes—but I wouldn’t hire an SEO/CRO agency just because you want more leads. First, determine whether your bottleneck is traffic, conversion, or lead quality. SEO gets qualified people to the site; CRO turns more of those visitors into inquiries. The two work best together.
Look at your last 90 days and calculate:
Website visitors → leads → qualified leads → sales
For example:
That immediately tells you where the opportunity is.
If you doubled traffic but kept the same conversion rate, you'd double leads—but if you can increase conversion from 1.5% to 3%, you double leads without buying another visitor. CRO is specifically about systematically improving that conversion rate.
I'd examine your:
Common improvements include making the value proposition immediately obvious, adding stronger proof/testimonials/case studies, reducing form friction, and giving visitors a clear next step.
Don't make the CTA simply "Submit." Make it communicate the benefit—e.g. "Get My Free Estimate" or "Book a 15-Minute Consultation." Testing different CTAs, forms, copy and page layouts is a core CRO practice.
I'd prioritize keywords that indicate someone is actually looking for what you sell—not just high-volume informational keywords.
For example, there's a huge difference between:
"how does commercial roofing work" and
"commercial roofing contractor near me" The second is much closer to revenue.
Build/optimize pages around your services + customer types + problems + locations where appropriate. Also make sure your technical SEO, page titles, internal linking, structured data and search appearance are solid. Google specifically notes that structured data can help it understand page content and potentially enable richer search features.
This is where many SEO agencies fall down.
Don't let an agency report:
"Organic traffic increased 47%!" while your sales haven't changed.
You want reporting like:
Organic search → lead → qualified lead → opportunity → customer → revenue
That lets you discover that, say, 500 visitors from one keyword produce 20 junk leads while 80 visitors from another produce 8 serious prospects.
Revenue per organic visitor is much more interesting than traffic.
Possibly—but I'd hire one only after asking them to diagnose the business first.
I'd favor an agency if:
I'd probably not hire one yet if:
In that situation, I'd fix the fundamentals first.
I'd interview 3 agencies and give all of them the same brief:
"Here's our website, traffic, leads and revenue. Diagnose the biggest constraints on generating qualified leads and give us a prioritized 90-day plan." A good agency should be able to tell you what they'd change and why, rather than immediately selling you 20 blog posts/month.
Ask:
I'd also insist on monthly experimentation and prioritization, not just a static SEO checklist.
For most businesses, I'd structure it roughly like this:
Month 1: Analytics + SEO + conversion audit ↓ Months 1–2: Fix major technical/on-page issues + improve highest-value pages ↓ Months 2–3: Build high-intent SEO content/pages + launch CRO experiments ↓ Months 3–6: Double down on pages/keywords that generate qualified opportunities ↓ Ongoing: Test → measure → improve → reinvest
The key is that SEO and CRO shouldn't be two separate projects. If SEO brings you 5,000 additional visitors but your website is bad at converting them, you've simply created a bigger leaky bucket.
If you give me your website URL, what your business sells, your typical customer value, and roughly how many monthly visitors/leads you currently get, I can give you a much more concrete assessment of whether you should hire an agency, what kind, and what I'd have them do first.
"Organic traffic increased 47%!" while your sales haven't changed.
You want reporting like:
Organic search → lead → qualified lead → opportunity → customer → revenue
That lets you discover that, say, 500 visitors from one keyword produce 20 junk leads while 80 visitors from another produce 8 serious prospects.
Revenue per organic visitor is much more interesting than traffic.
Possibly—but I'd hire one only after asking them to diagnose the business first.
I'd favor an agency if:
I'd probably not hire one yet if:
In that situation, I'd fix the fundamentals first.
I'd interview 3 agencies and give all of them the same brief:
"Here's our website, traffic, leads and revenue. Diagnose the biggest constraints on generating qualified leads and give us a prioritized 90-day plan." A good agency should be able to tell you what they'd change and why, rather than immediately selling you 20 blog posts/month.
Ask:
I'd also insist on monthly experimentation and prioritization, not just a static SEO checklist.
For most businesses, I'd structure it roughly like this:
Month 1: Analytics + SEO + conversion audit ↓ Months 1–2: Fix major technical/on-page issues + improve highest-value pages ↓ Months 2–3: Build high-intent SEO content/pages + launch CRO experiments ↓ Months 3–6: Double down on pages/keywords that generate qualified opportunities ↓ Ongoing: Test → measure → improve → reinvest
The key is that SEO and CRO shouldn't be two separate projects. If SEO brings you 5,000 additional visitors but your website is bad at converting them, you've simply created a bigger leaky bucket.
**To get more leads from your website, you must combine SEO (Search Engine Optimization) to drive targeted traffic with CRO (Conversion Rate Optimization) to turn those visitors into buyers, and you should hire an agency only if you lack the internal time or specialized skills to execute them effectively** **.**…
To get more leads from your website, you must combine SEO (Search Engine Optimization) to drive targeted traffic with CRO (Conversion Rate Optimization) to turn those visitors into buyers, and you should hire an agency only if you lack the internal time or specialized skills to execute them effectively .
Watch this video to understand how to evaluate whether an SEO partner is focused on generating real pipeline and leads rather than just superficial traffic:
11:16
How to Hire the Right SEO Agency and Avoid the Most ...6 days ago
YouTube · Stratabeat
| Factor | When to Hire an Agency | When to Handle In-House |
|---|---|---|
| Budget | You have a dedicated marketing budget to invest monthly for long-term ROI. | Cash flow is tight and you need immediate, zero-cost fixes. |
| Time & Expertise | Your team lacks specialized technical, copywriting, or analytical skills. | You have internal staff who understand your core customer and have open bandwidth. |
| Growth Goals | You want to scale rapidly and need multi-channel strategic execution. | You are a small local shop testing basic website updates. |
If you want to narrow this down, tell me:
I can help you prioritize your next immediate step.
Getting more leads from your website comes down to two main pillars: driving the right traffic to your site (**SEO** - Search Engine Optimization) and converting that traffic once they arrive (**CRO** - Conversion Rate Optimization). ### How to Get More Website Leads - **Optimize for High-Intent Keywords** : Focus on…
Getting more leads from your website comes down to two main pillars: driving the right traffic to your site (SEO - Search Engine Optimization) and converting that traffic once they arrive (CRO - Conversion Rate Optimization).
Whether you should hire an agency depends on your budget, internal expertise , and timeline.
To help figure out the best path forward, tell me:
I can help you decide whether an agency makes sense right now or if a DIY approach is better.
No sources cited
Yes—but **I wouldn’t hire an SEO/CRO agency immediately**. First, figure out *where the leak is*. Otherwise, you can end up paying an agency to generate more traffic to a website that doesn't convert. ## The lead-generation formula Think of website leads as:
Yes—but I wouldn’t hire an SEO/CRO agency immediately. First, figure out where the leak is. Otherwise, you can end up paying an agency to generate more traffic to a website that doesn't convert.
Think of website leads as:
Qualified traffic × conversion rate × lead quality = revenue
You need to improve all three, but in the right order.
Before changing the site, track:
This is particularly important because Google recommends optimizing lead-generation campaigns toward meaningful downstream actions—such as qualified or converted leads—not merely form fills or clicks.
If you can't currently tell which marketing channel produces actual customers, that's the first thing I'd fix.
I'd start with your highest-traffic/highest-value pages.
A good service-business landing page should make these questions immediately obvious:
What do you do? Who do you do it for? Why should I trust you? Why should I choose you instead of the alternatives? What should I do next?
Your primary CTA should be extremely obvious—e.g. Get a Quote, Book a Consultation, Call Now, etc.
Google's own guidance emphasizes clear calls-to-action, easy contact methods, mobile usability, relevant landing-page content, and minimizing friction.
I'd also test:
And don't overlook speed. Google specifically identifies landing-page speed and mobile experience as important areas to evaluate.
SEO should be more than "write 50 blog posts."
For a lead-generation business, I'd prioritize:
The goal isn't "more organic traffic." It's more organic traffic from people who are likely to become customers.
Possibly, but I'd be selective.
I'd consider an agency if:
I would not hire one just because they promise:
"We'll get you to #1 on Google." Instead, ask them:
There's an important distinction:
SEO gets people to the website. CRO gets more of those people to contact you.
Some agencies are excellent at one and mediocre at the other.
If your site gets, say, 10,000 relevant visitors/month and converts 1%, that's 100 leads.
Getting conversion rate from 1% → 2% gives you 200 leads without generating another visitor.
That's why I'd want an agency to demonstrate that they can improve the economics of the whole funnel, not just increase your traffic.
I'd run a 30-day diagnostic before signing a long-term agency contract:
Week 1: Analytics, Search Console, CRM and conversion-tracking audit Week 2: SEO/competitor/keyword audit Week 3: CRO audit of your top 5–10 pages Week 4: Implement the highest-impact fixes and establish a baseline
Then decide whether you need an agency.
If you'd like, send me your website URL and I can do a practical SEO/CRO review of it—looking at your messaging, pages, CTAs, SEO opportunities, conversion friction and competitors—and tell you whether I'd hire an agency at all, and what I'd want them to do first.
If you'd like, send me your website URL and I can do a practical SEO/CRO review of it—looking at your messaging, pages, CTAs, SEO opportunities, conversion friction and competitors—and tell you whether I'd hire an agency at all, and what I'd want them to do first.
Yes, an SEO/CRO agency **can** help you get more leads — but whether you should hire one depends on what is currently limiting growth. A good agency should not just promise “more traffic”; it should help you increase **qualified visitors, conversion rate, and sales pipeline**. SEO brings the right people in, while CRO…
Yes, an SEO/CRO agency can help you get more leads — but whether you should hire one depends on what is currently limiting growth. A good agency should not just promise “more traffic”; it should help you increase qualified visitors, conversion rate, and sales pipeline. SEO brings the right people in, while CRO helps more of those people take action.
A practical way to think about it:
Look at your current numbers:
Before hiring anyone, make sure you can measure:
Common lead-generation improvements include:
A website that looks good but does not guide visitors toward an action often behaves more like a brochure than a sales tool.
Look for an agency that focuses on revenue, not just rankings:
Modern SEO lead generation is increasingly about attracting people with specific problems and guiding them toward conversion, rather than chasing high-traffic keywords.
A strong CRO partner should:
Be cautious of agencies that immediately recommend a full redesign without first showing evidence of what is broken.
An agency is usually worth considering if:
You may not need an agency yet if:
Ask potential agencies:
Avoid:
If you share:
I can help you determine whether your bottleneck is more likely SEO, CRO, or something else — and what kind of agency (if any) would be a good fit.
Getting more leads from your website comes down to two sides of the same coin: **driving the right traffic** (SEO / AI search visibility) and **converting that traffic** once it arrives (CRO).[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QF-MaO61qg8&t=109) [[1]](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QF-MaO61qg8&t=109) How to Get More…
Getting more leads from your website comes down to two sides of the same coin: driving the right traffic (SEO / AI search visibility) and converting that traffic once it arrives (CRO).
How to Get More Website Leads
Should You Hire an Agency for SEO and CRO?
Whether you should hire an agency depends on your internal bandwidth, budget, and how critical organic growth is to your core business model.
To help narrow down the best path, tell me:
