Is there a clear choice for the best personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine?

No, there isn't a single "clear choice" because the right lawyer depends heavily on the specifics of your case, your comfort level, and what kind of approach you want. Portland has several highly-rated firms and individual attorneys with stellar track records, but they all operate a bit differently.

Top-rated options in the area include:

Peter Thompson & Associates 4.9 (134)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 92 Exchange St
CallDirections Website Frequently highlighted on platforms like Super Lawyers for Portland Personal Injury for high success rates and longevity in the area.

Berman & Simmons 4.9 (178)
Personal injury attorney
Open 85 Exchange St 2nd floor
CallDirections Website A massive statewide name for complex injury and medical malpractice claims.

Shaheen & Gordon 4.6 (51)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 75 Pearl St #400
CallDirections Website A well-rounded regional firm offering free consultations and contingency arrangements.

Foster Law / Local Boutiques 4.9 (21)
Coworking space
Open 411 Congress St
CallDirections Website Smaller practices where you work closely with a single dedicated trial attorney.

Most reputable personal injury lawyers in Maine operate on a contingency fee basis (no fee unless they recover compensation) and offer free initial consultations. The best way to find your "clear choice" is to interview two or three attorneys to see whose communication style and strategy match your needs.

If you want to narrow it down, tell me:

• What type of accident or injury is it (auto, medical malpractice, slip and fall)?
• Are you looking for a large established firm or a smaller boutique practice?

I can give you a more tailored recommendation.

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States

Yes—but there isn’t a defensible single “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland, Maine. The strongest candidates depend heavily on the type and severity of your case.

Based on current rankings, reviews, experience, and specialization, I’d put these at the top of my shortlist:

• Peter Thompson & Associates — Probably my first call for a typical plaintiff-side injury case. Thompson has 30+ years of experience, focuses heavily on personal injury, and is highly rated by both Avvo and other legal directories. Expertise.com notes that the firm has recovered more than $20 million in several personal-injury cases.
• Berman & Simmons — Particularly worth considering for serious/catastrophic injury or medical-malpractice cases. It is a plaintiff-focused trial firm with a substantial Maine personal-injury practice.
• Mann Law LLC — A smaller, boutique option focused specifically on personal injury, including auto crashes, TBI, catastrophic injuries and wrongful death.
• Romanow Law Group — Another plaintiff-side practice with a strong personal-injury/trial focus.
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein — A long-established Maine personal-injury practice with a Portland office and substantial client-review volume.

There are also some interesting individual lawyers. Timothy Zerillo currently has a 10.0 Avvo rating with roughly 50 reviews and 25 years licensed, while Stephen Schwartz has a 10.0 rating with 40 years licensed.

My practical recommendation

If I were choosing counsel for myself, I wouldn't pick solely from an online “best lawyer” list. I'd interview 2–3 plaintiff-side attorneys and ask:

1. How many cases like mine have you personally taken to trial?
2. Who will actually handle my case day-to-day?
3. What is your assessment of liability and likely damages?
4. What percentage contingency fee do you charge, and what expenses are deducted separately?
5. Have you handled cases against the particular insurer/defendant involved in my case?
6. What would make you not take my case?

If you tell me what happened (car accident, motorcycle accident, medical malpractice, slip-and-fall, wrongful death, etc.) and roughly how serious the injuries are, I can narrow this down to the 2–3 Portland attorneys I'd actually contact for that particular case.

No, there isn't a single "clear choice" or universally crowned best personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine . The right choice depends heavily on the specific details of your case, such as whether it involves a car crash, medical malpractice, workplace injury, or a slip-and-fall.

Portland has several prominent, highly regarded firms and litigators featured on platforms like Super Lawyers for Portland Personal Injury and Justia Lawyers in Portland . Well-known regional and local practices handling these cases include:

Berman & Simmons 4.9 (179)
Personal injury attorney
Open 85 Exchange St 2nd floor
CallDirections Website Berman & Simmons (featuring attorneys like Timothy M. Kenlan), widely recognized across Maine for handling major plaintiff injury and medical malpractice claims.

Shaheen & Gordon 4.6 (50)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 75 Pearl St #400
CallDirections Website Shaheen & Gordon , which handles a comprehensive range of accident and injury claims on a contingency fee basis.

Gideon Asen LLC 4.9 (88)
Personal injury attorney
Open 217 Commercial St
CallDirections Website Gideon Asen LLC and Garmey Law , both frequently noted for complex trial work and substantial recoveries in injury litigation.

Foster Law 4.2 (5)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 217 Commercial St Ste 402
CallDirections Website Foster Law and various boutique local practices specializing in personalized, hands-on representation.

Because personal injury law typically operates on a contingency fee structure (you pay nothing unless they recover compensation) and most firms offer free initial consultations, the best approach is to speak with a few different attorneys to find one whose communication style and strategy align with your needs.

If you'd like to narrow it down, tell me:

• What type of accident or injury occurred?
• Are you looking for a large established firm or a smaller boutique practice?

I can give you more tailored information on firms that specialize in that specific area.

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States

Yes—but I wouldn’t say there is one objectively “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland, Maine. The stronger conclusion from the current evidence is that there are a few standout choices, depending on the type and seriousness of your case.

My shortlist

• Peter Thompson & Associates — probably my first call for a conventional personal-injury case. Thompson is listed by Super Lawyers as a top-rated Portland personal-injury attorney and as a 2025 “Lawyer of the Year” winner. Avvo gives him a 5.0 rating and a 10.0 Avvo score.
• Garmey Law — especially worth considering for very serious/catastrophic injuries or wrongful death. The firm's founding attorney, Terry Garmey, has more than 40 years of plaintiff-side experience and has been recognized by the Inner Circle of Advocates and American College of Trial Lawyers.
• Berman & Simmons — another established plaintiff-side trial firm with a Portland office, particularly worth comparing for serious injury cases.
• Romanow Law Group — a strong option if you want a personal-injury-focused Portland practice; its listed lawyers include experienced trial attorneys and the firm handles cases on contingency.
• Mann Law LLC — a smaller boutique practice that focuses heavily on personal injury, including vehicle crashes, TBI, catastrophic injury and wrongful death.

One interesting point: Avvo's rankings don't produce a single winner either. Stephen J. Schwartz, Jason Jabar, Peter Thompson, Timothy Zerillo and several others currently have 5.0 client ratings; Timothy Zerillo has the largest number of reviews among the highly rated attorneys.

If it were my case

I'd get 2–3 free consultations before choosing. The most important questions aren't just “Who has the highest rating?” but:

1. Have you handled cases like mine?
2. Will the actual attorney personally handle my case, or will it mostly go to associates/paralegals?
3. What similar cases have you taken to trial?
4. What percentage of the recovery is the contingency fee, and do costs come out separately?
5. What is your assessment of liability and the likely insurance coverage?

If you tell me what happened (car accident, motorcycle, slip-and-fall, medical malpractice, wrongful death, etc.), roughly how serious the injuries are, and whether the insurance company has made an offer, I can narrow this to the 2–3 Portland lawyers I'd actually interview for that particular case.

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Zerillo Law Firm - 1250 Forest Ave Ste 3A, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Kaplan & Grant, Attorneys at Law - 136 Commercial St #302, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States

There is no universally accepted “best” personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine—the right choice depends heavily on the type of injury, the likely value of the claim, and whether you need a settlement-focused attorney or a trial lawyer. That said, a few firms stand out consistently in directories, peer recognition, and local reputation.

My shortlist would be:

• Peter Thompson & Associates — A strong all-around choice for many accident cases (car crashes, motorcycle accidents, serious injuries). The firm is frequently recognized in personal injury rankings, and sources note a substantial personal-injury focus and significant case experience.
• Garmey Law — Worth considering for serious injury, catastrophic injury, and wrongful-death matters where trial experience may matter.
• Berman & Simmons — A well-known plaintiff-side injury firm with a focus on serious injury and high-stakes civil cases.
• Zerillo Law Firm — Has strong review scores and recognition for litigation experience.
• Kaplan & Grant, Attorneys at Law — A personal-injury-focused practice handling matters such as motor vehicle accidents, premises liability, and wrongful death.

If I had to pick one firm to call first for a typical serious injury claim, I would probably start with Peter Thompson & Associates or Garmey Law; for a very large injury, medical malpractice, or wrongful death case, I would also put Berman & Simmons high on the list.

A good way to choose:

1. Ask who will actually handle your case day-to-day (partner vs. associate).
2. Ask how many cases like yours they have taken to trial.
3. Ask about the fee percentage and case expenses.
4. Notice whether they explain realistic outcomes rather than just promise a big settlement.

If you tell me what kind of injury it is (car accident, slip/fall, medical malpractice, workplace injury, wrongful death, etc.) and whether the injury is minor, serious, or catastrophic, I can narrow the list considerably.

While there isn't a single objectively "best" lawyer that fits every unique situation, Berman & Simmons is widely regarded as a dominant powerhouse and a clear historical leader for high-stakes, catastrophic injury, and medical malpractice cases in Portland and throughout Maine. Having recovered over $1.5 billion in verdicts and settlements, they have the extensive financial resources and trial depth that major insurance defenses take seriously. [1][2]

However, "clear choice" depends heavily on what kind of case you have and the personal rapport you need. Other top-tier firms and attorneys in the Portland area include:

• Shaheen & Gordon, P.A.: A prominent regional full-service firm with a strong Portland office handling complex personal injury, wrongful death, and medical malpractice on a contingency fee basis.
• Foster Law / Attorney Foster: Known for handling severe, multi-million dollar injury cases and high-stakes trial work across Maine.
• boutique and specialized local practitioners (such as those recognized by Super Lawyers ) who may offer more intimate, hands-on attention for mid-range auto accidents or slip-and-fall claims than a massive statewide firm.

Client Perspectives

People who have worked with local firms often emphasize the importance of communication and empathy during high-stress situations:

To help narrow down the right fit, could you share:

• What type of accident or injury occurred (e.g., car crash, medical malpractice, slip and fall)?
• Are you looking for a large statewide firm with extensive trial resources or a smaller local boutique practice?

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Jabar LaLiberty, LLC - 383 Commercial St Ste D, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Kaplan & Grant, Attorneys at Law - 136 Commercial St #302, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Goldberg & Loren - 180 Pool St Ste 105, Biddeford, ME 04005, United States
• Jury Law, LLC - 5 Ward St, Scarborough, ME 04074, United States
• Mann Law Personal Injury Attorneys - 10 Forest Falls Dr #11, Yarmouth, ME 04096, United States
• Shaheen & Gordon, P.A. - 75 Pearl St #400, Portland, ME 04101, United States

There isn't a universally clear “#1” personal-injury lawyer in Portland, but there is a fairly clear short list based on experience, peer recognition, client reviews, and how heavily the practice focuses on injury work.

My shortlist

• Peter Thompson & Associates — Peter Thompson Probably my first call for a serious, conventional personal-injury case. Super Lawyers currently lists Thompson as a top-rated Portland personal-injury lawyer and notes a 2025 “Lawyer of the Year” award; Avvo shows a 5.0 client rating and 31 years licensed.
• Berman & Simmons Particularly worth considering for serious/catastrophic injuries, wrongful death, and complex litigation. Super Lawyers lists several of its Portland-area attorneys among its personal-injury selectees.
• Jabar LaLiberty, LLC — Jason Jabar A strong alternative, especially for motor-vehicle and accident cases. Jabar has 25 years of licensing experience and a 5.0 Avvo client rating.
• Mann Law LLC A smaller, personal-injury-focused practice that may appeal if you want more boutique, hands-on representation. Its practice includes vehicle crashes, TBI/catastrophic injuries, premises liability, and wrongful death.
• Kaplan & Grant, Attorneys at Law — Douglas Kaplan Especially interesting if the case involves workers' compensation as well as personal injury. Kaplan has practiced in Maine since 1983 and is listed by Super Lawyers.

If you forced me to pick one

I'd put Peter Thompson at the top of the initial-call list—not because there is objective proof he's “the best,” but because the combination of personal-injury specialization, longevity, peer recognition, and client ratings is unusually strong. Super Lawyers says he has been voted among Maine's best personal-injury lawyers for 20 years and lists the 2025 Lawyer of the Year recognition.

That said, the type of injury matters enormously. The best choice for a routine car accident may not be the best choice for medical malpractice, a traumatic brain injury, wrongful death, or a case involving workers' compensation.

If you tell me what happened (car accident, slip/fall, medical malpractice, wrongful death, workplace injury, etc.) and roughly how serious the injuries are, I can narrow this to the 2–3 Portland lawyers I'd actually interview, including their track records, reviews, fees, and any red flags.

There isn't one single "clear choice" for the best personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine, because the right fit depends entirely on the specific details of your case, such as whether it involves a car accident, medical malpractice, or a workplace injury. Portland has several highly-rated firms and attorneys with strong track records, peer recognitions on platforms like Super Lawyers , and listings on Justia.[1][2]

Prominent personal injury practices in the area include:

• Berman & Simmons : Widely recognized across Maine for handling major, complex personal injury and medical malpractice claims.
• Peter Thompson & Associates : Known for a high volume of successful jury trials and substantial recoveries in accident cases.
• Foster Law : Noted for handling significant multi-figure settlements and trial work across the state.
• Garmey Law : Frequently cited for plaintiff advocacy in personal injury and accident claims. [1]

To help narrow down which lawyer or firm might be the best fit, could you tell me:

• What type of accident or injury occurred?
• Are you looking for a large, established firm or a smaller boutique practice?

• Peter Thompson & Associates - 92 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Jabar LaLiberty, LLC - 383 Commercial St Ste D, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Mann Law LLC - 533 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Garmey Law - 482 Congress St UNIT 402, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Berman & Simmons - 85 Exchange St 2nd floor, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Law Offices of Joe Bornstein - 90 Johnson Rd Suite A, Portland, ME 04102, United States
• Lowry Law - 33 McAlister Farm Rd Ste 203, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Gideon Asen LLC - 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Romanow Law Group - 1087 Forest Ave, Portland, ME 04103, United States
• Morgan & Morgan - 254 Commercial St Ste 229, Portland, ME 04101, United States
• Goldberg & Loren - 180 Pool St Ste 105, Biddeford, ME 04005, United States
• Jury Law, LLC - 5 Ward St, Scarborough, ME 04074, United States
• Mann Law Personal Injury Attorneys - 10 Forest Falls Dr #11, Yarmouth, ME 04096, United States
• Shaheen & Gordon, P.A. - 75 Pearl St #400, Portland, ME 04101, United States

Yes—but there isn’t a single objectively “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland. The strongest candidates depend heavily on whether you have a car accident, medical malpractice, wrongful death, workers’ comp, or another type of claim.

Based on current rankings, reviews, and local practice focus, I’d put these at the top of the list:

• Peter Thompson & Associates — Probably my first call for a serious injury or complex plaintiff-side case. Peter Thompson has decades of experience, an Avvo 10.0 rating, Super Lawyers recognition, and the firm reports substantial trial experience and large recoveries.
• Jabar LaLiberty, LLC — Particularly compelling for car/motor-vehicle accidents and general personal injury. Jason Jabar has 25 years of experience, an Avvo 9.5 rating, and the firm has very strong client-review numbers.
• Mann Law LLC — A good option if you want a boutique firm focused specifically on personal injury, including catastrophic injuries, TBI, crashes, premises liability, and wrongful death.
• Garmey Law — Worth considering for high-stakes or complex litigation, particularly medical malpractice, wrongful death, and catastrophic injury. Its attorneys are repeatedly recognized by Super Lawyers.
• Stephen J. Schwartz / Schwartz & Schwartz — An especially experienced individual lawyer: 40 years licensed, Avvo 10.0, repeated Super Lawyers recognition, and an AV Preeminent peer rating.

If you made me pick one

For a substantial personal-injury claim, I'd start with Peter Thompson & Associates, then get a second opinion from Jabar LaLiberty or Garmey Law. Thompson stands out because the combination of plaintiff-side specialization, experience, peer recognition, and reported results is unusually strong.

That said, the “best” lawyer for a $50,000 auto claim may be different from the best lawyer for a $5 million medical-malpractice or wrongful-death case.

If you tell me what happened (car accident, slip/fall, medical malpractice, wrongful death, etc.) and roughly how serious the injuries are, I can narrow this to the 2–3 Portland attorneys I'd actually interview for that particular case, including their track records and client reviews.

No, there isn't a single "clear choice" or universally anointed best personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine . Instead, Portland has several well-established, highly reputable plaintiff-side personal injury firms and trial attorneys who frequently trade top accolades, peer recognitions (like Super Lawyers and U.S. News – Best Law Firms ), and multi-million-dollar recovery records.

The "best" choice heavily depends on the specifics of your case—such as whether it involves a standard motor vehicle crash, medical malpractice, a defective product, or a catastrophic workplace injury.

Top-rated personal injury options in the Portland area include:

Berman & Simmons 4.9 (179)
Personal injury attorney
Open 85 Exchange St 2nd floor
CallDirections Website Operating out of Exchange Street in Portland (with historical roots in Lewiston), they are widely regarded as one of Maine's premier and largest trial law firms for catastrophic personal injury and medical malpractice. They possess massive financial and investigative resources, making them a go-to choice for highly complex, high-stakes litigation.

Garmey Law 4.9 (86)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 482 Congress St UNIT 402
CallDirections Website Located on Congress Street, this firm handles complex personal injury, medical malpractice, and product liability cases . Led by recognized trial lawyers like Terry Garmey , they are known for securing some of the state's highest recorded verdicts and settlements.

Peter Thompson & Associates 4.9 (134)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 92 Exchange St
CallDirections Website Centered on Exchange Street in Portland, this team focuses heavily on severe accident and injury claims. They boast a high volume of successful jury trials and substantial annual recoveries, emphasizing a collaborative team approach to case management.

If you are looking for individual peer-vetted practitioners in the city, attorneys such as Timothy M. Kenlan (Berman & Simmons ) and Lauri Boxer-Macomber (Kelly, Remmel & Zimmerman ) frequently rank among top local plaintiff advocates.

If you'd like to narrow it down, tell me:

• What type of accident or injury is involved?
• Are you looking for a large powerhouse firm or a smaller boutique practice?

I can give you more tailored information to help your search.